Find beach hotels in Shelter Island, NY

"The hotel is one of a kind. Beautifully located just across from the

in a quiet area. Very little, practically zero traffic. The room was very comfortable. All rooms are overlooking the bay. The

was quiet and the water amazing for swimming. The personnel was kind and helpful. We even had ice delivered to the

by the Ice Man :) There are several restaurants within a short drive. I recommend Commander Cody’s Fish Market (casual, great seafood). We were there on Tuesday and the bar...

"Ingrid’s house is magical. We stayed here for 4 days and had everything we needed. The pool was glorious. Sitting by the pond with the bullfrogs and turtles while listening to the multitudes of bird sounds was serene. Our kids playing badminton and ping pong, taking a respite from their swimming was perfect. This house and its garden, with spectacular trees was magical in every way. We felt truly lucky to have found this oasis. And the short walk to the

another wonderful bonus. We had...

"We had a wonderful stay in Shleter island and are definitely planning to be back. The house is beautiful, very well equipped, comfortable and welcoming. The hosts were helpful and the location is amazing."

"We had the most amazing time at this awesome property. The owners and property managers were on top of everything and the communication was A++. The home was updated and comfortable although we pretty much lived in the pool through our stay. The location was great .. Quiet yet close to the most beautiful beaches and great restaurants. We had a blast ferry hopping to the hustle and bustle of North/South Forks but we all loved coming back to this quiet retreat. Cannot wait to come back!!"

"Property great. Beautiful home with great amenities"

"Such a wonderful home for our family of 7 to escape the cares of the world for a fun summer respite! The house and guest cottage are both beautifully appointed and but not too fancy so everyone could gather comfortably together in many spaces! The bedrooms are well appointed, towels and bed linens are luscious! All bedrooms have AC and fans.Two bathrooms are small, downstairs bathroom is large and beautiful. Kitchen is completely stocked with everything you need. We loved the water view on the...