Find Beach Hotel in Montclair Colony, Shelter Island

"The property "

"Lovely hotel. Family rooms were very spacious and perfect for the 4 of us. Pool area really clean and lots of sunbeds. Breakfast was great and good choice. We had an issue with a very noisy neighbour, which was dealt with and we were moved rooms the next day, as well as security helping in the night. Riverhead is a nice area, can recommend Cuccino pizza."

"The Wednesday barbecue was so much fun!"

"Lovely friendly staff, very clean, modern hotel room with a great coffee machine. Worth noting that you need a car to stay here. We took an uber into Hampton Bays which worked out very well for us. "

"Beautiful place, super friendly, and the food is amazing. Plus tons of amenities."

"Staff responsive to all inquires. Indoor & outdoor pools well maintained. "

"Feels like a remote vacation destination just a couple of hours from home. Self-contained property with private beach and pool away from crowds and tourists, but close to town."

"Property maintain nice and very clean and private."

"Barons Cove Inn is very well located i.e. walkable to pretty much everything. It’s also charming, somewhat quirky, clean, comfortable, has very nice room amenities and internet access, a friendly attentive staff, a nice bar and restaurant, a lovely pool, is waterfront and has a great front porch with rockers. What’s not to like? We’ll definitely be making return visits. "