Find Hotels with a Pool in Shelter Island, NY

"Room was very spacious and peaceful, clean and comfortable. Great experience "

"There are no words to say how amazing this property is. Like stepping back to the past where the customer service, quality of the linens and rooms and absolute attention to detail not only still exist but thrive at this place. The onsite restaurant was a 15 out of 10, and again service above and beyond so many places in this day and age. I am truly grateful and appreciative of the attention to the customers and details that are clearly their mission and it shows. They make you feel so welcome and like a family member. Incredible, we will be back."

"This place was great. Brought in my service dog and had no issues. Room was immaculate and comfortable and the shower was huge which felt incredible coming back to after a long day at the beach. The walls in our suite were unfortunately on the thinner side and we could hear snoring coming from our neighbors room. Luckily everything else about the stay was fantastic, would book again. "

"Great time beautiful property"

"Great location !! Room was spacious and very comfortable and clean !!!"

"Great prices, huge room, convenient and super friendly staff. Have stayed the past 3 weeks for business, good location"

"Very nice "

"Staff was very helpful. Check in was easty. Pool was clean. "

"Beautiful location. Staff was friendly and helpful. Dining was delicious. Rooms were renovated and spacious "