Find Hotels with a Pool in Shelter Island, NY from CA $105

"Nice staff and the hotel is fine. "

"The people that work heere are the absolute nicest!"

"Place is All Time! "

"Walkable to the beach. Have to cross a highway which was not as wide or busy, so it was easy."

"Older hotel and room decor but obvious a lot of effort is put into presenting the property to its highest potential. "

"Small, but comfortable room. Excellent location right on the beach. There was a mix up with our dinner at the hotel one night and my husband’s dinner came out much later than mine. It wasn’t a big deal, but the hotel comped our meal, brought us a free dessert, and comped our post-dinner drinks at the bar. The nightly s’mores were a wonderful touch and encouraged guests to socialize with each other. Would absolutely stay here again!"

"Our luxury 2 bedroom suite was very nice, clean, and spacious. We had a huge balcony with a view of the Long Island sound"

"Beautiful place, very clean, great staff. Can’t be the proximity to town and right on the water! Left my glasses and they mailed them immediately! "

"Uûcrcndfhyyh)like gg"