Find Hotels with a Pool in Shelter Island, NY

"Bed was comfortable. Shower was very good. "

"I would definitely return to this Hyatt. Although a little far away from the wedding I was attending, the families had arranged shuttles. I enjoyed the quietness of the outdoor pool while having a marina as a backdrop. The fact that the weather was absolutely perfect made that more enjoyable. The staff inside were friendly and attentive. Although my rate didn’t include breakfast, for $11 there was a buffet with a nice assortment of eggs, cereals, yogurt, etc. The aquarium is right next door and there restaurants all around the hotel on Main St. "

"Thank you Adrian. She was wonderful and made my mother’s birthday special. Every interaction we had with the staff was positive. The halyard served a delicious lobster roll in a beautiful setting. We will be back. "

"I love this property. But, very disappointed in the pool and lack of variety of food "

"The staff was great, older hotel but in good shape. "

"Great property "

"Reasonable accommodation in premium location. Great find"

"Need bigger bathroom counters"

"We treated ourselves to room service one rainy night and it was great. The housekeeping staff was attentive and professional, one young woman offered to help get my bag upstairs! Super location for my needs of daily Tracy Anderson studio work Lovely spot"