Search Penn Yan Cottage Rentals from CA $116

"I ended up reserving this property kind of last minute after a previous cabin I was interested in fell through (It was another cabin listed in Naples and the owner ended up being EXTREMELY unstable! I HIGHLY recommend that if you were looking at that other cabin to go with this one instead. You will be much safer! There is something seriously wrong with the other guy!). As soon as I pulled up I knew I had made the correct choice. Great scenery, great interior. A ton of games to play. And that...

"The cottage had everything you would wish for. Great neighborhood and close to downtown. It also had access to a private beach which was great to hang out at during a really hot spell."

"We loved the property! It was very clean, a great space and the hosts were very responsive! Would absolutely recommend"

"The house and area were oerfect fir a relaxing quiet stay. Love the decor."

"The property was awesome for our two couple group. We love the fingerlakes and spend a lot of time here. So much nicer( and cheaper) than staying at a hotel. The house was cute and cozy. Nice porches for hanging out. We were tasting Saturday and Sunday, it’s a perfect location. We will be back. The home owner was very easy and available to communicate with."

"loved the cozy little cabin in the woods with squirrels leaping from tree to tree. Enjoyed coffee on the spacious porch, the comfy furniture indoors, and all the thoughtful accessories available."

"Best place I’ve ever stayed at a finger lake! Cozy and comfortable cottage. A feeling of home. View was impeccable! Very clean! Just so relaxing with the family. My 3 year old granddaughter loved the kayak. First time in the kayak. She didn’t want to come out! lol! My lab loved every bit of it! Met the hosts. Very welcoming and friendly! Definitely staying there again. Thank you so much for a fun filled girls weekend! Kim Schaffer"

"Nice. Cozy cottage !!!!! Host seemed to think of all our needs and beautiful peaceful ! So thankful to have visited !!!"

"Gary’s place was just what the doctor ordered. Cozy and clean, well-stocked, and secure. Gary’s communication was fantastic - he gave a heads-up on the sneaky railroad underpass to get to the house (which was totally fine for my sedan), and checked in at the beginning and ending of my stay. Very dog friendly! My pup absolutely loved the backyard and dock, and at 11 years old, she had her first experience with using a doggie door. Great location for quiet R&R, small town exploring (Geneva and...

"not a comfortable environment at all, cabin was full of bugs and cob webs everywhere, have to pay for guest’s to come visit. They say speed limit 5 mph but they zoom around on go carts going past cars, then tell the cars to slow down, because you’re not white!!!!!!! Most horrible experience ever!!! Then got police called on us as well!!!!! "

"Nice place. Clean, private, and in a good location."

"Perfect location Only suggestions would be the ladder to the water didn’t feel safe as the hooks didn’t line up and the couch needs replacement Otherwise a good stay!"

"Sally and George are great hosts. The house is located at a convenient location with an unbeatable lake view. The house is 20 mins drive from Watkins Glen state park. Checkin/checkout was a very easy process. House View was unbeatable. We had a great time! Thanks Sally and George!"

"Property was as advertised. No issues and great location near best winery and breweries. Great views from the deck and dock."

"Cannot say enough wonderful things about this tiny house. We had clean towels, a kitchen,cleaning supplies, and we left a few logs of wood for the fire pit that we didn't use. If you like privacy,this was perfect. Its almost as if you are out in the woods even though you are right next to the main road."

"Second year staying at the shore house. House is very clean and sets on the shore line.Close to great fishing grounds and nicely maintained at with a reasonably priced. We loved coming back and will come back anytime we come to Lake Cyuga and the senica area.."

"It was so clean and cute! Perfect area from restaurants and wineries! We loved the little walk to the lake and loved the chairs on the deck! Thank you so much for sharing your beautiful cottage with us!"

"Open floor plan worked well for our family. The many outdoor sitting areas was a real plus."

"After descending 73 stairs with luggage and groceries, the vacation home was a little slice of paradise. Lovely ❤️."