Search Guest Houses in Shelter Island from CA $330

"Great location ,beautiful hotel,nice staff"

"We have stayed at a lot of different places over the years, But this by far was our best trip to date. The property was all that was promised. Clean and beautiful. It’s a must stay if your heading to Montauk."

"The salt water pool was awesome! Would have liked it a little bit warmer. Breakfast was great, eggs, sausage, English muffins, bagels coffee,tea, waffles, fruit, cereal, juice! Rooms were spacious with fridge. Would highly recommend "

"very nice and organized"

"Nice staff and the hotel is fine. "

"The people that work heere are the absolute nicest!"

"Place is All Time! "

"The staff was excellent. Very friendly and accommodating. And the room was comfortable and clean."

"The staff was very friendly. We were only there for 2 days but the hotel seemed well maintained. It's nice that there is both an indoor and an outdoor pool. "