Find a Bed and Breakfast in Shelter Island from CA $271

"Bathroom very clean. Staff is super friendly. Ate at the restaurant and it was delicious. "

"Room was clean but furnishings were from the dollar store. Spacious, practical, and clean in a great location. "

"WE HAD A LOVELY WEEKEND. SERVICE WAS EXCELLENT. "

"Yes "

"Imagine a Super 8 motel or even something lower‑level that just put in new furniture and a new bathroom, but everything else stayed the same. It’s really not worth this price, to be honest. The rooms are clean but actually very small, and the hotel isn’t on the beach, there’s a dune and a road in between. Very bad insulation, you can hear people and their TVs from the rooms next to you."

"The checkin staff and later that evening were a 5. Checkout we were not happy with. My daughter got sick and we asked for 12 checkout for her room only. We didn’t say she was sick. She said 11:30. She didn’t tell anyone as housekeeping came to room at 11:20. We called and again asked for time - she said she can have a “few minutes”. We don’t stay at Quality Inns but travel a lot and have never been told no to a later check if needed it. BTW the parking lot was pretty empty so I don’t think they “needed that one room”. Again the younger girl at checking was great and the gentleman later that night were great. "

"Had a hard time getting room cool enough to sleep ??"

"Wonderful experience from beginning to the end. Our check in was friendly, fast and easy efficient . Ethan and John were amazing. Room "

"Beautiful property near a picturesque town. I would definitely recommend. I’d love to return soon! "