Find vacation rentals that suit your style
Our top choices for City Island cottages




1. Riverfront Cottage w/ Heated Pool, Hot Tub & Fireplace, 35 min to NYC
Riverfront Cottage w/ Heated Pool, Hot Tub & Fireplace, 35 min to NYCGreenwich
10.0 out of 10, Exceptional, (15 reviews)
10/10
Exceptional
(15 reviews)
"Beautiful and restful"
"Beautiful and restful"Lisa H.
The price is CA $1,152
CA $1,152
CA $2,173 total
includes taxes & fees
Nov 19 - Nov 20
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Learn more about City Island
Head to sights like City Island Nautical Museum as you discover the local area in City Island.

Top reviews in City Island




The Muse New York
The Muse New YorkManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Nice
Nice
Tumkirat




Pod Times Square
Pod Times SquareManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Great location with a short walk to Times Square, theatres, restaurants, subway, bus terminal, etc. Rooms are basic, but clean and modern. Bed was comfortable. Would recommend to anyone looking for a short stay in midtown Manhattan, and would stay here again on my next trip.
Great location with a short walk to Times Square, theatres, restaurants, subway, bus terminal, etc. Rooms are basic, but clean and modern. Bed was comfortable. Would recommend to anyone looking for a short stay in midtown Manhattan, and would stay here again on my next trip.
Liam




INNSiDE by Meliá New York Nomad
INNSiDE by Meliá New York NomadManhattan
10/10 Excellent
My friend and I stayed here in one of the double bed rooms. Cozy place to hang out. Lobby and amenities are nice. Free juices and water!
My friend and I stayed here in one of the double bed rooms. Cozy place to hang out. Lobby and amenities are nice. Free juices and water!
Shalana




Hyatt Regency Times Square
Hyatt Regency Times SquareManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Close to Times Square, the staff were really friendly, since our flight landed so early they let us check in early and even upgraded us to a corner room with a view of Times Square and the city. We also asked for a late checkout and they were able to accommodate that. We will definitely stay here again
Close to Times Square, the staff were really friendly, since our flight landed so early they let us check in early and even upgraded us to a corner room with a view of Times Square and the city. We also asked for a late checkout and they were able to accommodate that. We will definitely stay here again
Romulo




Arlo Midtown
Arlo MidtownManhattan
8/10 Good
Overall a good location and fairly clean. The cleaning people did not clean our room in time and kept checking in even though we told them to come back at a certain time.
Overall a good location and fairly clean. The cleaning people did not clean our room in time and kept checking in even though we told them to come back at a certain time.
Navid




CIVILIAN Hotel
CIVILIAN HotelManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Overall, a great hotel for a short stay! The room was fantastic, and the value for the location was hard to beat. There were a few minor downsides, though. Breakfast was underwhelming and the front desk wasn't always staffed when we needed assistance. Nothing that significantly impacted our stay, but worth keeping in mind if you're planning a longer visit. For the price and location, I'd definitely recommend it!
Overall, a great hotel for a short stay! The room was fantastic, and the value for the location was hard to beat. There were a few minor downsides, though. Breakfast was underwhelming and the front desk wasn't always staffed when we needed assistance. Nothing that significantly impacted our stay, but worth keeping in mind if you're planning a longer visit. For the price and location, I'd definitely recommend it!
Lexi




PUBLIC, an Ian Schrager hotel
PUBLIC, an Ian Schrager hotelManhattan
8/10 Good
Nice staff and hotel perks
Nice staff and hotel perks
Benten




Artezen Hotel
Artezen HotelManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Great location
Great location
Yejin




Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Midtown East
Courtyard by Marriott New York Manhattan/Midtown EastManhattan
10/10 Excellent
The king bedroom and sofa bed has comfort room square for family. Location is close by Metro, so convince. There are rich options of various restaurants.
The king bedroom and sofa bed has comfort room square for family. Location is close by Metro, so convince. There are rich options of various restaurants.
Hai




The Lucerne Hotel
The Lucerne HotelManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Nous avons adoré le quartier environnant, avec multitudes de bons restaurants, magasins, et Central Park à seulement quelques minutes de marche. Coin également très calme. Notre chambre était très propre et grande.
L'air conditionné est efficace mais fait du bruit.
Le personnel est toujours très courtois et prêt à aider.
Nous avons adoré notre séjour.
Nous avons adoré le quartier environnant, avec multitudes de bons restaurants, magasins, et Central Park à seulement quelques minutes de marche. Coin également très calme. Notre chambre était très propre et grande.
L'air conditionné est efficace mais fait du bruit.
Le personnel est toujours très courtois et prêt à aider.
Nous avons adoré notre séjour.
Marie-Pascale




Arlo NoMad
Arlo NoMadManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Always a great stay!
Always a great stay!
Lindsay




Hilton Garden Inn New York Times Square South
Hilton Garden Inn New York Times Square SouthManhattan
8/10 Good
L
L
Krista




Hotel Belleclaire Central Park, a Small Luxury Hotel
Hotel Belleclaire Central Park, a Small Luxury HotelManhattan
10/10 Excellent
I absolutely loved everything about Hotel Belleclaire. The location on the Upper West Side is perfect. The neighbourhood is charming to stroll through, close to the park and it’s incredibly convenient to jump on the subway and head downtown in no time. The rooms were super clean and comfortable and the lobby bar and cafe are lovely. The staff were also wonderful and went out of their way to make us feel welcome. Looking forward to my next stay!
I absolutely loved everything about Hotel Belleclaire. The location on the Upper West Side is perfect. The neighbourhood is charming to stroll through, close to the park and it’s incredibly convenient to jump on the subway and head downtown in no time. The rooms were super clean and comfortable and the lobby bar and cafe are lovely. The staff were also wonderful and went out of their way to make us feel welcome. Looking forward to my next stay!
Susan




Little Charlie Hotel
Little Charlie HotelManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Clean room and great location! Would come back again.
Clean room and great location! Would come back again.
Sumayah




Motto by Hilton New York City Chelsea
Motto by Hilton New York City ChelseaManhattan
8/10 Good
It was great! Room was small but big enough for a city stay. Bed was super comfortable and I liked the minty soaps and shampoo. The drinks at the bar downstairs were great also! It was a great location and easy to walk to restaurants, parks, shops, and a great location for attending an event at MSG. My only little complaint would be there was no coffee machine in the room. I love a morning Nespresso in bed at a hotel. (Especially when it’s been a party weekend… which isn’t that what’s happening...
It was great! Room was small but big enough for a city stay. Bed was super comfortable and I liked the minty soaps and shampoo. The drinks at the bar downstairs were great also! It was a great location and easy to walk to restaurants, parks, shops, and a great location for attending an event at MSG. My only little complaint would be there was no coffee machine in the room. I love a morning Nespresso in bed at a hotel. (Especially when it’s been a party weekend… which isn’t that what’s happening...
David




The Cloud One New York-Downtown, part of the Motel One Group
The Cloud One New York-Downtown, part of the Motel One GroupManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Solid choice
Solid choice
Robert




Staypineapple, An Artful Hotel, Midtown
Staypineapple, An Artful Hotel, MidtownManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Second time staying at this location and was very pleased - again! Fantastic location for anything close to MSG, MoMa, Times Square... tons of shopping and places to eat nearby. Central Park is walkable in about 30 minutes, too. Rooms are very small, so be efficient with what you bring -- but clean and comfortable, which is most important. Great staff.
Second time staying at this location and was very pleased - again! Fantastic location for anything close to MSG, MoMa, Times Square... tons of shopping and places to eat nearby. Central Park is walkable in about 30 minutes, too. Rooms are very small, so be efficient with what you bring -- but clean and comfortable, which is most important. Great staff.
Lisa




Belvilla District 6 Residences, Battery Park, Financial District
Belvilla District 6 Residences, Battery Park, Financial DistrictManhattan
10/10 Excellent
Loved staying here, big space and convenient access to public transit
Loved staying here, big space and convenient access to public transit
Maria












