Find Hotels by Independent in Tappan Lake

"We had everything we needed and more. They went above and beyond for their guests. We will definitely be back. It was quiet and relaxing and beautifully decorated. Very cozy and homey. "

"Didn't like that the staff (cleaning people didn't ck to see if we needed clean towels)"

"Great price and clean rooms. Just needed a place to sleep and this was perfect."

"Super clean and wonderfully nice. Very timley as well"

"Very worn down, room smelled of smoke terribly even though non smoking, floors filthy, doors and trim falling apart. Was recently “renovated “ a few years ago by slapping on paint to try to cover flaws. Lobby had awful food smell. Appears management lives in the hotel/lobby full time. "

"Nice hotel. The bath water was warm but not hot. The stopper in the tub closed but wouldn’t open up. I had to pry it open. The room was nice and clean. The staff was excellent! Breakfast was good. We didn’t use the pool or hot tub. The soda machine took my money, and when I told the front desk attendant she said “yeah it took mine a few days ago” but obviously she didn’t label the machine as not working. "

"I chose this hotel based on its positive reviews, but unfortunately our experience didn’t match. We were placed on the 4th floor despite noting during booking that we were traveling with an 18-month-old, and within the first 10 minutes we had a noise complaint called on us, which was frustrating given the circumstances. I asked to be moved to a lower floor, but the request was refused due to a wedding party staying at the hotel. I was told they couldn’t downgrade me to a queen room, which was disappointing as we were simply looking for a more practical arrangement with a young child. The pool was advertised as heated, but it was very cold and not enjoyable to use. Additionally, the pillows were quite uncomfortable, which made it difficult to get a good night’s sleep. Overall, I was disappointed, especially since I had higher expectations based on the reviews. Needless to say, I will not be staying here in the future."

"Staff was soo friendly upon arriving! Loved the looks and back story of the building! Loved the location in a quiet, put back, and safe place off of the freeway! Breakfast was amazing! Loved the french vanilla creamer for coffee! The pool and hot tub area was so relaxing and clean! Our room was pretty clean but few areas I was a little uncomfortable in at first due to other people's hair on the floor and in corners of the bathroom and on tub side! Other than that, the bathroom was pretty much clean! The room itself was spacious, cute and accommodating and mostly clean! Overall stay, I'd rate it all together a 4.8 out of 5! I do recommend this hotel though considering cleaning every knook and cranny isn't the easiest with multiple rooms! "

"Nice, quiet get away! Cute cabin with great back porch and hot tub. Great communication with host. We would stay again. "