10 Best Hotels in Montclair Colony, Shelter Island for 2025

Montclair Colony hotels and places to stay

"Phenomenal property and our room had a private sand patio. Service was extremely attentive and friendly. The beach was very spacious and pretty clean."

CA $367 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 3 - Sep 4

Studio Unit Upper Oceanfront 'San Remo' | Terrace/patio

"Great stay and beautiful clean room "

CA $465 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 4 - Sep 5

"Quiet peaceful beautiful "

CA $746 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 11 - Sep 12

"It waa great for traveling with kids. Close to the beach and my kids loved the indoor pool!"

CA $306 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 1 - Sep 2

Ocean View 2BD Corner King and Queen | Living area

"Easy checking in and out Easy access few steps to beach from first floor unit "

CA $333 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 7 - Sep 8

Beach nearby, white sand, sun loungers, beach umbrellas

"The Roundtree was one of the most peaceful hotels we’ve ever stayed in. I highly recommend for a romantic getaway. "

CA $2,139 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 17 - Aug 18

"Unique property; lots of attention from staff; close to town."

CA $2,417 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 9 - Sep 10

"We had a good stay at The Journey. Can’t wait to come back! "

CA $740 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 3 - Sep 4

"Great stay! Easy and convenient. Nice room with cute patio out to pretty backyard of resort. Short walk to pool."

CA $570 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 2 - Sep 3

"Great experience at a wonderful property!"

CA $1,030 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 1 - Sep 2

"Very profesional, very good experiencia , the host the best , the property beatiful 100 porcent recomended"

CA $1,079 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 2 - Sep 3

"Great property."

CA $923 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 2 - Sep 3

"The staff was incredibly genuine and the property felt intimate and comfortable."

CA $1,082 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 17 - Aug 18

"Great staff "

CA $1,199 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 17 - Aug 18

"Beautiful property, but no restaurant open for lunch, no pool service, no one to answer calls at front desk. Constant marketing notices."

CA $1,393 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 2 - Sep 3

"HIDDEN GEM IN THE HEART OF HAMPTONS! What a special place to stay in the Hamptons! I am so happy we found this wonderful gem! This hotel is clean, quiet and well managed. The pool is beautiful the rooms are modern, sleek and clean! The grounds are beautifully manicured. The location is perfect! This new hotel has the charm of a bed and breakfast. The hotel is a short car ride from either East Hampton or Southampton which is perfect if you chose to explore all the little towns the Hampton's has...

CA $2,045 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 17 - Aug 18

"The location was great, the room was clean, and the staff were very friendly and accommodating."

CA $562 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 1 - Sep 2

"Beautiful property and amazing staff, I will definitely be back soon!"

CA $952 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 1 - Sep 2

"Great location and very comfortable "

CA $831 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 1 - Sep 2

"Great location Rooms are very small but still amazing "

CA $746 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 4 - Sep 5

Where to stay in Montclair Colony

Find the best Montclair Colony areas and neighborhoods for the activities you enjoy most.

Menantic Creek

If you're looking for some top things to see and do in Menantic Creek and surrounding area, you can visit Wades Beach and Sunset Beach.

See properties

Silver Beach

While Silver Beach might not have many sights to explore, venturing just a little farther will lead you to top things to see and do like Crescent Beach and Sunset Beach.

See properties

Coecles Harbor

When in Coecles Harbor, you can plan a visit to Shelter Island Whale's Tail and Gardiner's Bay Country Club, some noteworthy sights in the nearby area.

See properties

Hay Beach

Hay Beach might not have many top sights, but Gardiner's Bay Country Club and Greenport Carousel are two attractions nearby that you can check out.

See properties

Shorewood

While there might not be top attractions in Shorewood, you can explore the larger area and discover places like Wades Beach and Sunset Beach.

See properties

Top Montclair Colony Hotel Reviews

Sound View Greenport

10/10 Excellent

"This place is a real joy so much energy and lots to do. They are not overly fancy but worth the ride. "

Baron's Cove

10/10 Excellent

"Barons Cove Inn is very well located i.e. walkable to pretty much everything. It’s also charming, somewhat quirky, clean, comfortable, has very nice room amenities and internet access, a friendly attentive staff, a nice bar and restaurant, a lovely pool, is waterfront and has a great front porch with rockers. What’s not to like? We’ll definitely be making return visits. "

Hyatt Place Long Island East End

10/10 Excellent

"I would definitely return to this Hyatt. Although a little far away from the wedding I was attending, the families had arranged shuttles. I enjoyed the quietness of the outdoor pool while having a marina as a backdrop. The fact that the weather was absolutely perfect made that more enjoyable. The staff inside were friendly and attentive. Although my rate didn’t include breakfast, for $11 there was a buffet with a nice assortment of eggs, cereals, yogurt, etc. The aquarium is right next door and there restaurants all around the hotel on Main St. "

Water's Edge Resort & Spa

10/10 Excellent

"We stayed in the villas. Everything was absolutely perfect. My 88-year-old mom was able to be on the deck, enjoying the views while we were at the sound and in the pool. The staff was fantastic. Everything was spotless. The other guests were so respectful quiet- it was such an easy vacation. It was incredible."

Members save 10% or more on over 100,000 hotels worldwide when you’re signed in

Hotels in Montclair Colony, Shelter Island from CA $265

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Go beyond your typical stay in Montclair Colony

Check prices for these dates

Filter by

Montclair Colony hotels and places to stay

Driftwood Resort

Driftwood Resort

Sea Crest Resort

Sea Crest Resort

The Hermitage

The Hermitage

Ocean Vista Resort

Ocean Vista Resort

Windward Shores Ocean Resort

Windward Shores Ocean Resort

The Roundtree, Amagansett

The Roundtree, Amagansett

The Reform Club

The Reform Club

Journey East Hampton

Journey East Hampton

East Hampton House Resort

East Hampton House Resort

Mill House Inn

Mill House Inn

East Hampton Art House Bed & Breakfast

East Hampton Art House Bed & Breakfast

The Huntting Inn

The Huntting Inn

The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn

The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn

The Hedges Inn

The Hedges Inn

EHP Resort & Marina

EHP Resort & Marina

Wainscott Woods Retreat

Wainscott Woods Retreat

The Sagaponack

The Sagaponack

A Room At The Beach

A Room At The Beach

Topping Rose House

Topping Rose House

Baron's Cove

Baron's Cove

Where to stay in Montclair Colony

Menantic Creek

Silver Beach

Coecles Harbor

Hay Beach

Shorewood

Top Montclair Colony Hotel Reviews

Sound View Greenport

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Hotels in top Shelter Island neighborhoods

Hotels near popular Shelter Island Attractions

More Accommodation Types in Montclair Colony

Hotels Close to Nearby Airports

Montclair Colony Hotels by Brand

Explore more hotels

More ways to book

Expedia's Latest Trends