Find beach hotels in Shelter Island, NY from CA $1,106

"The property "

"The staff was knowledgeable and courteous. The cleaning crew cleaned the room exceptionally well. The view of the ocean from the room was breathtaking. I will definitely go back. "

"Lovely hotel. Family rooms were very spacious and perfect for the 4 of us. Pool area really clean and lots of sunbeds. Breakfast was great and good choice. We had an issue with a very noisy neighbour, which was dealt with and we were moved rooms the next day, as well as security helping in the night. Riverhead is a nice area, can recommend Cuccino pizza."

"Beautiful and relaxing! Enjoyed it all! Great service! "

"Lovely friendly staff, very clean, modern hotel room with a great coffee machine. Worth noting that you need a car to stay here. We took an uber into Hampton Bays which worked out very well for us. "

"Right in the water…peaceful spot!"

"Feels like a remote vacation destination just a couple of hours from home. Self-contained property with private beach and pool away from crowds and tourists, but close to town."

"Food was amazing, bed was so comfy and clean, overall 10/10"

"Barons Cove Inn is very well located i.e. walkable to pretty much everything. It’s also charming, somewhat quirky, clean, comfortable, has very nice room amenities and internet access, a friendly attentive staff, a nice bar and restaurant, a lovely pool, is waterfront and has a great front porch with rockers. What’s not to like? We’ll definitely be making return visits. "