Fishers Island Vacation Packages

I was very impressed with how attentive the staff was here. They are all extremely professional and very welcoming. Most hotels no longer daily room cleaning services, but here, they do. They went above and beyond keeping my room clean and well stocked with towels. This entire hotel is clean and very beautiful in general. The beds are comfortable, the rooms are bigger than expected, the bathrooms are newly renovated with excellent water pressure. On top of that, the rooms truly are sound proof! I never heard my neighbors on either side one time. If you are looking for a place to stay that is also very convenient for transportation and walking, look no further. You'll be more than pleased with your stay here.

Loved everything about it

The hotel was phenomenal! We were greeting so warmly on arrival and given great dining and neighborhood tips by Ben- who was wonderful. The rooms were beautiful and all aspects of the hotel and dining/ bar spaces were gorgeous and full of character. We enjoyed The Portrait Bar a couple of times and had such fun. We also had breakfast in the restaurant and a spectacular dinner at Cafe Carmellini. I wish I could remember our server’s name because she was top notch. I will go back to The Fifth Avenue Hotel. It was a wonderful experience.

My wife and I stayed at the Allegria Hotel from August 15-17. Overall, our stay was ok. Nothing special. Upon checking in on Friday night, our safe was locked, our phone wasn’t working, there was food that was previously left in our fridge from the previous guests and also the vanity mirror looked like there were hair particles from someone shaving. Not sure if our room was thoroughly cleaned before we checked in. We went to front desk to let them know about the phone, but didn’t tell them about the other things because it was late and we just wanted to sleep. Maintenance came Friday night, but couldn’t get the phone to work. He said he’ll come back on Saturday and fix it, but never did. The weekend we did not have a phone, and Saturday night our floor was very noisy when we were trying to sleep, but we did not have a phone to call and make a noise complaint. We were on the 3rd floor, room 308. The only positive thing about the hotel is the beach and its surrounding area. Other than that, the price to pay for a weekend isn’t worth it in my opinion. We are local New Yorkers, in our early 30s, that just wanted a weekend away, to a location that’s nearby.