Search Motels in Put-in-Bay from CA $44

"The property is somewhat secluded but yet in the middle of everything. There is no pool on the property but there is public access to the pools of the adjacent properties. There is no housekeeping and you have to help turn the property over (take out trash, strip beds, ect). Would definitely stay here again."

"Very clean and close to everything we wanted to go to"

"We stayed here on a Monday night and had a great experience. Friendly accommodating staff. Very clean. Pool area was nice and there is an outside bar as well. I would stay here again!"

"Staff was awesome and very accommodating!"

"Great stay close to the park "

"Clean , easy check in , and friendly staff"

"We had a wonderful experience at the Islander Inn. I was initially uncertain after reading some older reviews, but I’m very glad I paid attention to the more recent ones, which reflect the positive changes under the new ownership. The owners are actively involved onsite, which is evident in the level of care and attention given to the property. The rooms and common areas were exceptionally clean, and the staff—from the front desk to the poolside bartenders—were consistently welcoming, attentive, and professional. The atmosphere throughout the hotel felt inviting and well-maintained. The pool bar was another highlight; the drinks were excellent and generously prepared. Overall, the Islander Inn exceeded our expectations, and it will be our preferred place to stay whenever we visit Put-in-Bay. "

"Great place "

"The breakfast options were amazing, rooms were so clean. Everything about this place was just stunning, decor so fitting. 10/10"