Greencastle Vacation Rentals

Change your mind

Book hotels with free cancellation

Treat yourself

Be picky

Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check prices for these dates

Next weekend

In two weeks

In one month

In two months

Browse Select Greencastle Vacation Homes

Our top choices for Greencastle vacation homes

"Really enjoyed how clean and well maintained the place is. Great location on the water with privacy!"

On the beach, sun loungers, beach towels

"We had a blast staying here, our first time on Eleuthera. The beach in front of the house was the best of anywhere on the island. We're coming back next year and hope to stay at the same house. Thank you for renting us your place."

"The property itself was run down and dirty. The location was great."

"Perfect location, beautiful beach, excellent food nearby at the club and super-helpful staff. The house isn't new or shiny, if that's what you're looking for, but it worked well for us. We had a great week and can't wait to go again. Thank you to everyone there!"

"Wonderful house and location. Loved every minute of our stay ."

"Great stay with the family in Tarpon Bay. Hosts took great care. We will be back for sure 😊"

"We had such a great time and amazing, relaxing and private vacation here. Can’t wait to come back"

"Our 4 night stay was okay but could have been much better with a bit more attention to both the house itself and to the communication.Upon arrival, the power was out. We’re familiar with power outages on island but without WiFi and sketchy cell service in the area, we had to drive 20 minutes down the road to inquire about the outage. We learned from the host- we never did get a response from the property manager- that there was a scheduled power outage that day and power would be back on in a...

"The home is in a beautiful beachfront location. It has nicely appointed rooms and was extremely clean. I would recommend it to friends and would stay again."

"Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: Pointe House was a lovely place to stay."

"Eleuthera means freedom, and free we felt. Atop a little hill sits the Bahamian farm house, tucked away by native bush and trees. The house fills with warm light and cool breeze. It is true and pure island living in the best say. "

"Tara Estate worked well for us as we primarily came to fish out of Davis Harbor, which is relatively close by. The house had a few “quirks”, but they were expected as it is nearing 90 years old. However, the property managers, a Shorlette and Joey, were amazing and made sure we were comfortable and satisfied. Thanks for a great two weeks in Tara Estate!"