A lighthouse, a red-roofed building, and a wooden structure near a coastal area.

Find Historic Hotels in Fire Island, NY from CA $554

  • Change your mind

    Book hotels with free cancellation

  • Treat yourself

    Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
    Sign in

  • Be picky

    Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check availability on Fire Island Historic Hotels

Tonight
Sep 11 - Sep 12
Tomorrow
Sep 12 - Sep 13
This weekend
Sep 11 - Sep 13
Next weekend
Sep 18 - Sep 20

Our top choices for Fire Island historic hotels

A room with a wooden table and benches, large windows, and a hanging light fixture.
A staircase with wooden steps leading to a landing, white walls, and a round mirror on the right.
A wooden deck leading to a building with a fenced area, surrounded by greenery.
A modern house with a wooden deck, a dining area with a table and chairs, and a covered grill area.

1. Fire Island Beach House Ocean Bay Park

Fire Island Beach House Ocean Bay Park
Ocean Beach
United States
Mohit M.
CA $1,103
CA $1,981 total
includes taxes & fees
Sep 20 - Sep 21
Fire Island Beach House Ocean Bay Park
A covered outdoor seating area with string lights, a table, and chairs.
A modern kitchen with dark wood cabinets, a stainless steel microwave, and an oven. There is a dining table with white chairs and a rug.
A kitchen with white cabinets, a built-in microwave, and a coffee maker.
A bedroom with a bed, a chandelier, a dresser, a nightstand, and a window.

2. 4 BR. 2 BTH, HOT TUB, MINS TO JONES BEACH, MINS TO RIVIERA WALK TO TRAIN TO NYC

4 BR. 2 BTH, HOT TUB, MINS TO JONES BEACH, MINS TO RIVIERA WALK TO TRAIN TO NYC
Massapequa
United States
Ari P.
CA $3,451
CA $5,847 total
includes taxes & fees
Sep 27 - Sep 28
4 BR. 2 BTH, HOT TUB, MINS TO JONES BEACH, MINS TO RIVIERA WALK TO TRAIN TO NYC
A large, historic building with a symmetrical garden featuring geometrically shaped ponds and neatly trimmed hedges.
A covered outdoor seating area with tables and chairs, a view of a parking lot, and a railing with decorative ironwork.
A spacious library with a fireplace, bookshelves, and comfortable seating areas.
A restaurant with brick walls, arched windows, and chandeliers. Tables are set with white tablecloths and chairs.

3. Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate

Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate
Huntington
United States
Lamy
CA $485
CA $554 total
includes taxes & fees
Sep 30 - Oct 1
Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate
View all properties

Top Fire Island Hotel Reviews

The Atlantic Hotel

The Atlantic Hotel

10/10 Excellent
"it was a clean bright comfortable room .Super cozy bed and pillows ,wonderful jacuzzi tub! A nice touch with an espresso machine in the room! Parking was easy and close to everything needed."
Amy 1-night trip
Posted 1 hour ago
The Atlantic Hotel
Hilton Long Island/Huntington

Hilton Long Island/Huntington

10/10 Excellent
"Front desk staff was amazing"
Gina Rhona 1-night trip
Posted 5 hours ago
Hilton Long Island/Huntington
Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham

Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham

10/10 Excellent
"10/10 will definitely be back!!"
Precious 4-night trip
Posted 10 hours ago
Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

8/10 Good
"Overall ok"
sam 1-night trip
Posted 16 hours ago
Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island
Hampton Inn Garden City Long Island

Hampton Inn Garden City Long Island

10/10 Excellent
"we were there for a quick trip and everyone was accommodating, the breakfast was delicious, and the kids had a great time in the pool."
Karen 1-night trip
Posted 19 hours ago
Hampton Inn Garden City Long Island
Hilton Garden Inn Westbury

Hilton Garden Inn Westbury

10/10 Excellent
"Last minute booking but the staff made everything simple and easy . Great food in the area"
Steven 2-night trip
Posted 19 hours ago
Hilton Garden Inn Westbury

Explore a world of travel with Expedia