Cheap Flights to Fire Island , NY from CA $214

View CA $214 flight on Sun, May 24, 2026Opens in a new window

Popular airlines

  • American Airlines

  • Delta

  • JetBlue Airways

  • Alaska Airlines

  • United

  • Spirit Airlines

  • Lufthansa

  • Be in the know

    Get alerts if flight prices drop or rise*

  • Book smarter

    Save up to 30% on select hotels after you book a flight*

  • Earn twice

    Earn your airline miles on top of our rewards
    Sign in

How much is the cheapest flight to Fire Island?

Prices were available within the past 7 days and start at CA $214 for one-way flights and CA $353 for round trip, for the period specified. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms apply.

Porter Airlines
Sun, May 24 - Sun, May 31
YYZ
Toronto
EWR
New York
CA $353 Roundtrip, just found
CA $353
Roundtrip
just found
Select Porter Airlines flight, departing Sun, May 24 from Toronto to New York, returning Sun, May 31, priced at CA $353 just found
American Airlines
Mon, May 4 - Wed, May 6
YYZ
Toronto
LGA
New York
CA $362 Roundtrip, just found
CA $362
Roundtrip
just found
Select American Airlines flight, departing Mon, May 4 from Toronto to New York, returning Wed, May 6, priced at CA $362 just found
Air Canada
Mon, May 4 - Wed, May 6
YYZ
Toronto
JFK
New York
CA $362 Roundtrip, just found
CA $362
Roundtrip
just found
Select Air Canada flight, departing Mon, May 4 from Toronto to New York, returning Wed, May 6, priced at CA $362 just found
Delta
Mon, May 4 - Wed, May 6
YYZ
Toronto
LGA
New York
CA $362 Roundtrip, just found
CA $362
Roundtrip
just found
Select Delta flight, departing Mon, May 4 from Toronto to New York, returning Wed, May 6, priced at CA $362 just found
United
Thu, Jul 30 - Wed, Aug 12
YYZ
Toronto
EWR
New York
CA $362 Roundtrip, found 2 days ago
CA $362
Roundtrip
found 2 days ago
Select United flight, departing Thu, Jul 30 from Toronto to New York, returning Wed, Aug 12, priced at CA $362 found 2 days ago

Frequently asked questions

How do I find cheap flights to Fire Island that have flexible change policies?
It's quick and easy with Expedia. Firstly, enter your preferred travel dates and click on the "Search" button. Next, check "No change fee" directly underneath the "Flexible change policies" subheading on the left-hand side of your screen. Step 3. Reserve a cheap and flexible airfare to Fire Island.
Which airlines fly to Fire Island?
With a good selection of airlines flying to destinations in or near Fire Island, discovering more of this region is a snap. Book a seat with one of these quality carriers:

  • Delta - 11,603 flights to or near Fire Island each month, including 6,403 flights to LaGuardia Airport (LGA) and 4,446 to John F. Kennedy Intl. Airport (JFK) per month.
  • United Airlines - 9,341 flights to or near Fire Island each month, including 8,404 flights to Liberty Intl. Airport (EWR) and 937 to LaGuardia Airport (LGA) per month.
  • American Airlines - 6,452 flights to or near Fire Island each month, including 3,850 flights to LaGuardia Airport (LGA) and 1,999 to John F. Kennedy Intl. Airport (JFK) per month.

How can I find cheap tickets to Fire Island?
One of the best ways to get a hold of cheap tickets to Fire Island is to be flexible with your dates. Search for your flights, then click "flexible dates" above the results. It'll reveal the cheapest prices for nearby days. The lowest price for a flight to Fire Island in the last seven days was CA $353. Booking in advance will usually help you score an even better deal.
How much is a flight to Fire Island?
The cost of a round-trip flight to Fire Island in the last seven days fluctuated between CA $353 and CA $362. If you were flying one way out of Toronto (YYZ), you could have picked up a deal from just CA $214.
What are the most popular airports to fly into in Fire Island?
You're spoiled for choice in Fire Island. Once you've decided what city you want to visit in the region, choosing one of these leading airports will be simple:

  • LaGuardia Airport (LGA) - 13,394 flights per month.
  • Liberty Intl. Airport (EWR) - 10,998 flights per month.
  • John F. Kennedy Intl. Airport (JFK) - 8,973 flights per month.

When is the cheapest time to fly to Fire Island?
Try to leave early in the week to bag a bargain airfare to Fire Island. Tuesday is routinely the most affordable day to take off, followed by Monday. Saturday often has the most expensive ticket prices. This is because a lot of travellers like to start their vacation on a weekend.
How much is a plane ticket to Fire Island?
Plane tickets to Fire Island varied from CA $353 to CA $362 in the last seven days. Usually, the sooner you make a reservation, the better the price.
What months are the cheapest to book a flight to Fire Island?
February is the most affordable month to book your Fire Island vacation. Tickets are at a premium over the festive month of December, so steer clear of this time if you can.

Travel information

Destination airport
Newark Liberty Intl. Airport
Destination airport IATA code
EWR
Destination city name
Newark Liberty Intl. Airport
Roundtrip price
CA $340

Trending flights to Fire Island

Prices were available within the past 7 days and start at CA $214 for one-way flights and CA $353 for round trip, for the period specified. Prices and availability are subject to change. Additional terms apply.

Porter Airlines
Sun, May 24 - Sun, May 31
YYZ
Toronto
EWR
New York
CA $353 Roundtrip, just found
CA $353
Roundtrip
just found
Select Porter Airlines flight, departing Sun, May 24 from Toronto to New York, returning Sun, May 31, priced at CA $353 just found

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

*Available to Expedia members.