Find beach hotels in Fire Island, NY from CA $450

"Fire alarm went off 3 times in 5 days and happened last year also. "

"Great stay"

"It was amazing the stuff the location everything was perfect. Great location for a staycation "

"The room was clean and comfortable except for the sofa bed. We had a party of three, which meant they offered us a king bed plus sofa bed. There were food bits and trash under the cushions and mattress, and the bed was not put together correctly as the foot either caused the bed to collapse or raised one’s feet up. Also, having a party of three it would have been nice to have three bath towels. The floor had been recently updated, which was nice but lingering with the “new” smells was the aroma of marijuana in a non-smoking hotel. The breakfast experience was mixed in that the food was adequate for most and the coffee not horrible, but all tables were a mess, the options for those of us with allergies were nearly non-existent, and we had the misfortune of having uncontrolled children running around screaming when we were there. Lastly, the parking isn’t ideal. It is primarily on the backside while the entrance and elevator are not. Overall, it is still a good nights sleep (if you keep the fan on as the walls are thin), the front desk staff are nice, and the room was adequately clean and updated."

"Took 45 minutes to checkin due to computer issues. First room offered smelled like smoke and was refused. Crib had been requested and confirmed a couple days earlier but was not setup in room. I had to insist that staff find one and set it up in the second room. Staff needed to be asked to do everything and acted like they were doing me a favor. For 250/night! "

"Great stay but need to fix those elevator’s , take too long . I ordered room service 10/10 nice hotel "

"We were there for a 1 night stay. Through our Hotels.Com booking, we received a $20 coupon to use in the hotel. Ok, we figured let have a couple of glasses of wine @the Bar before leaving for dinner. We requested Bar level wines (not too shelf) which were presented nicely. To our dismay, the cost of each glass of wine was $20. So, the bill was $40 + a $5 tip. We found that to be exorbitant. On checkout, we complained about the pricing but the front desk would/could not do anything to reduce that, claiming no Manager was available to assist. We were then directed to the Food Manager who also would/could not assisted but took our info and explained they would be alerted to our complaint. Waiting for a call. "

"Clean rooms, shopping mall nearby"

"Maria W., the front desk assistant was very helpful with me during check in .She Help resolve my issue and it made my stay more pleasant..thanks again Maria."