Modest Town Vacation Rentals

"The rental was great and staff was amazing!"

"Loved this property. It was our first pony swim and the front desk gave us excellent advice on where to park. It is a charming inn that felt like home away from home. Older property but extremely well kept. It was very quiet and the beds were very comfortable. Loved having breakfast and coffee available. We will be back!"

"Lady at check in was super friendly. Bed is comfy. Shower is great. Pillows need to be replaced. That is my only complaint. They don’t offer soaps and shampoos but to me that’s just a waste. I always bring my own. Towels were extremely nice for a hotel. Not super big but fluffy and clean. If they got new pillows this place would get five stars from me. I have stayed in a lot of high end hotels and this one is just as nice for a very reasonable price. "

"Owner was top notch!! Location close to everything!! "

"The property was beautiful and well-maintained. I would recommend Key West Cottages. I plan to visit again. 10/10 "

"This property was perfect for our stay at Chincoteague. I loved the hot tub, pool, and proximity to town for dinner and drinks. This is a great place to stay!"

"We attended the 100th year of pony penning in Chincoteague, VA. The hotel turned out to be in a great location to shuttles, festivities, and great places to dine. The rooms were nice, clean, and quiet. The rooms overlooking the bay are very nice."

"Nice and clean room, hotel is close to food and water. AC a little noisy. Staff very kind and helpful. Good breakfast. Easy parking. Good wifi. We had a very pleasant stay, thank you!"

"A good stay. Excellent staff. A Starbucks right next door was a nice bonus. The Chinese restaurant nearby was not very good. "