Book the Best HISTORIC Hotels in Bay Shore in 2026

A wooden boardwalk leading to a lighthouse surrounded by dense vegetation.

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Check availability on Bay Shore Historic Hotels

Tonight

Tomorrow

Next weekend

In two weeks

Our top choices for Bay Shore historic hotels

1. Fire Island Beach House Ocean Bay Park

Ocean Beach

James K.

CA $1,099

CA $1,932 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 1 - Sep 2

2. Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate

Huntington

Jasmine

CA $580

CA $663 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 25 - Aug 26

Coffee/tea maker, fridge, microwave, oven

4 bedrooms, desk, iron/ironing board, travel crib

3. 4 BR. 2 BTH, HOT TUB, MINS TO JONES BEACH, MINS TO RIVIERA WALK TO TRAIN TO NYC

Massapequa

Ari P.

CA $3,440

CA $5,963 total

includes taxes & fees

Sep 8 - Sep 9

View all properties

Top Bay Shore Hotel Reviews

Hyatt Regency Long Island

10/10 Excellent

"Overall a great place. Minimal noise even w 6 wedding parties in our experience. Breakfast was great and I am very picky."

Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

10/10 Excellent

"Buenas atenciones, nuestra habitación era limpiada cada día, me encantó."

Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island

10/10 Excellent

"This was our first time staying here. I am picky, but I was pleasantly impressed. The room was very clean, including the bathroom. Even the bath towels were better than some of the comparable hotels. Miyooki at the front desk was professional yet friendly. She always greeted us with a smile whenever we managed to be present during her shift. Little did she know that we were in town for a funeral and Miyooki’s warm and pleasant demeanor meant so much. If there was one thing that could be improved upon, it was the breakfast. I love a pot of hot steel oats. However, it was only available in the instant oatmeal packets. The sweet warm cinnamon rolls were a hit with our family though. We would certainly stay here again and think other front desk staff members should shadow Miyooki and observe how well she interacts with guests. I have a career in customer service spanning decades and industries, so I always take the time to complete surveys and compliment those who know what it means to deliver great service. Miyooki is a keeper!"

Marriott Melville Long Island

10/10 Excellent

"Great staff, clean room, bar was a little loud overall we love this Hotel and stay here every time we go to Long Island."

Hilton Long Island/Huntington

8/10 Good

"Our bathroom was very old and needed repairs. Paint all chipped and sink and shower were very old and used. Very surprising since our room was very nice. Expected more from a Hilton."

Holiday Inn Plainview-Long Island by IHG

10/10 Excellent

"Q"

Frequently asked questions

What should I expect on my historical trip to Bay Shore?

You'll probably want to seek out the sights of historical relevance while you're staying in Bay Shore. During your visit, why not also enjoy the many sights including the beaches?

How many historical hotels are located in Bay Shore?

In Bay Shore, there are 118 lodging options bookable on Expedia but not many designated as historic hotels.

What are the must-see historical places and other sights to visit in Bay Shore?

Bay Shore is notable for landmarks like Fire Island Lighthouse, Robert Moses Water Tower, and Bay Shore Historical Society. Cultural venues include YMCA Boulton Center for the Performing Arts, Teatro Yerbabruja, and Sagtikos Manor. A couple of additional sights to add to your agenda are Fair Harbor Ferry Terminal and Atlantique Beach.

What is a historic hotel like in Bay Shore?

Guests who choose a historic hotel can spend a night or two in a place that has a national historic designation. A castle, a palace or even a pub or an old police station can be turned into a historic hotel as long as it's a place of special interest. Traditional architecture and period features are typically found within the guestrooms or public spaces of such hotels in Bay Shore, giving a sense of history.

What is the difference between a historic hotel and a heritage hotel?

You'll often hear the term "heritage hotel" in Asia and Europe, while "historic hotel" is more common in the U.S. though overall the terms are quite similar. The architecture and actual building of a historic hotel tends to be what's most important. For a heritage hotel, it's often the cultural value as well as how it influenced the community.

Do historic hotels in Bay Shore have modern facilities?

Hotel interiors feature the modern conveniences and safety features you've come to expect, but every effort is made to preserve the historic aspects and traditions. WiFi, heating and air conditioning, updated bathroom facilities, and the usual amenities found in a hotel will also be available in a historic hotel. Rest assured that when you choose a historic hotel in Bay Shore, you won't find a place that's uncomfortable or rundown.

Explore a world of travel with Expedia

Book Historic Hotels in Bay Shore on Expedia.com

Find Historic Hotels in Bay Shore, NY from CA $663

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check availability on Bay Shore Historic Hotels

Our top choices for Bay Shore historic hotels

1. Fire Island Beach House Ocean Bay Park

2. Oheka Castle Hotel & Estate

3. 4 BR. 2 BTH, HOT TUB, MINS TO JONES BEACH, MINS TO RIVIERA WALK TO TRAIN TO NYC

Top Bay Shore Hotel Reviews

Hyatt Regency Long Island

Radisson Hotel Hauppauge-Long Island

Holiday Inn Express Hauppauge-Long Island

Marriott Melville Long Island

Hilton Long Island/Huntington

Holiday Inn Plainview-Long Island by IHG

Frequently asked questions

Explore a world of travel with Expedia