Find Cabins in Central Eleuthera for Rent

"We enjoyed our 10-day stay. The sweet house was everything we expected—Clean, well designed and organized, and close to Governor’s Harbor as well as points north and south. The weather was hotter than we expected, but AC worked well. I especially enjoyed daily “workouts in the small and very clean pool. Jethro, who lives nearby, was particularly helpful with suggestions for restaurants and activities. Highly recommend."

"This is a fantastic house in a fantastic location on a fantastic natural island. The house sleeps 8 very comfortably and provides every modern convenience. A refreshing pool is two steps from the back balcony door and diving and snorkeling are a mere 10 yards further in your private back yard with stairwell down to the water. Everyone loved jumping off the ledge into the crystal blue water. Beautiful views from every window in home. Great local restaurants just 3 miles down the road in lovely and quaint Governor’s Harbor. Gorgeous private pink sand beaches within 10 min drive. Twin Cove, French Leave and Banana Beach all were 5 stars! French Leave Resort and Pascal Beach resort with swim up bar added a feel of fine resorts. Locals are very friendly and the property owner responded promptly to all my texts."

"I have been going to Eleuthera for over 20 years. Every home is different and being on a remote island has its challenges for property owners. This home sits on a great beach with plenty of privacy. It was very clean and the check in process was super easy. Some items are worn, but everything works. The bed in the blue bedroom sways and is super soft (the only negative). Awesome view and nice location."

"I’m a solo traveler and my second stay at Daddy Joe’s was as special as the first. From the clean, fresh and comfortably appointed room to the exceptional staff and of course amazingly scrumptious food (both dining in and taking out), everything was easy, relaxed and delicious. I really appreciate the little touches and personal service that transforms a stay there from ordinary to extraordinary. Try the Daddy Joe’s burger and the garlic Parmesan wings! Gaulding Cay beach across the street was literally paradise. I cannot wait to return!"

"The water was beautiful and we really enjoyed the beach at rainbow bay. It’s challenging to get around the settlements because there are very few street signs or signage on businesses. Don’t be afraid to ask around for what you what. We found it to be the easiest."

"Trade winds was a beautiful property. Very private. The pool was perfect and the view was stunning. Close to beach and town. Host was responsive to any questions we had. We would stay here again."

"Privacy, beauty, setting and every possible convenience in a vacation rental on one of the out islands. Top appliances, comfortable furniture, spectacular setting on a near private beach of miles. And to make things best, a wonderful local manager—responsive, knowledgeable,etc. Could not have been more pleased! Compliments to the owners for their thoughtful furnishing and accommodations. A minor point would be the need to replace the beach chairs, but the many patio chairs and tables and lounges were in top condition and extremely nice. Almost fear providing this rating and having massive popularity preclude availability for us later (smile). It was a wonderful getaway."

"The Best!"

"Stephanie and her staff were wonderful. Her personable handling of our stay was fantastic."