Find Hotels by Independent in Big Pine Key from CA $291

"We had a great experience at Banana Bay! The room was beautiful and clean, and we had a balcony, which was so great. The pool was large and great to swim in. Banana Bay is also very centrally located in Marathon, so it was easy and convenient to get around (including to Sombrero Beach, which is a quick 10 min bike ride or 3 minute car ride away). Concierge and staff were all so polite. All in all, a great experience!"

"Front desk staff and wait staff were great! We stayed on our way to key west and on the way back we decided to stay again. In fact as we were getting ready to leave, we couldn’t think of a reason not to stay just one more night. So we ended up staying there three nights of our five night trip. The pools were great. There was live music at the outdoor bar. The view is beautiful! Definitely will stay there again."

"Clean, very hospitable, will return."

"Clean room. Wonderful breakfast."

"What a wonderful place to stay. Very beautiful and tranquil. If you are looking for things to do, it is there. Everyone there was extremely helpful and was quick to go out of their way to make sure your stay was enjoyable. "

"All of that + great location for phishing"

"Clean cozy room. Very friendly staff. Excellent location. I will book again."

"This place was top notch. Very hospitable when we checked in. The room was clean, the bed was comfortable, the coffee in the morning by the water was delicious and peaceful. The resort has kayaks and I was able to take one out in the morning and there were manatees that swam around me. It was beautiful! We had dinner down the street at the island fish company and it was one of the best meals we've ever had. Highly recommend all of it!"

"We really enjoyed our stay. It was something a little different, would have been a nice place to stay longer than 1 night. It slept 6 comfortably but only had the 1 twin bed in the loft where it could have fit 2 which would made it easier. The couch made a nice bed also but would not have had to make if 2 twins up there. Just a thought. It was clean and ready for us. Check in was great, we came late, the key was in the box. In the morning the girls were very welcoming. "