Find hotels in Shelter Island Heights, NY from CA $119

The best area to stay in Shelter Island Heights is the village area itself, particularly around the historic Shelter Island Heights Historic District.This district is the heart of the community, characterised by its historic Victorian homes and tree-lined streets. It's where you'll find most of the island's amenities, including shops, restaurants, and the ferry terminal for easy access to Greenport. The area is very walkable, making it convenient to explore on foot.For couples seeking a relaxing getaway, staying within the historic district offers a quintessential island experience. You'll be close to dining options and can enjoy strolls along the streets admiring the architecture, or head down to Crescent Beach for a peaceful afternoon by the water. Many accommodations here offer a more intimate setting great for two.Families often find the historic district appealing due to its proximity to activities. The village green provides open space for children, and the calm waters of Crescent Beach are suitable for swimming and building sandcastles.

One of the best hotels in Shelter Island Heights that travellers recommend is The Pridwin Hotel.The 4-star Pridwin Hotel, with an outstanding 9.6 rating, offers a wonderful experience with its private beach access and a refreshing poolside bar. Guests frequently highlight the beautiful and clean rooms, the amazing amenities, and the great facilities. Many rooms boast breathtaking water and ocean views, and premium bedding and bathrobes add to the comfort. The hotel is conveniently located just 0.4 km from Crescent Beach and 0.9 km from Sunset Beach, making it ideal for beach enthusiasts.

For families visiting Shelter Island Heights, The Pridwin Hotel and The Rams Head Inn are both excellent choices.The 4-star Pridwin Hotel, with an outstanding 9.6 rating, is a fantastic option for families. Guests frequently highlight the beautiful and clean rooms, amazing amenities, and great facilities. Families will appreciate amenities such as sofa beds, kids' meals, and a pool with a gate for added safety. Many rooms offer water or ocean views, adding to the relaxing experience. The hotel is also conveniently located near Sunset Beach, just 0.9 km away, and Crescent Beach, a mere 0.4 km away.Another good option is the 4-star Rams Head Inn, rated 7.6. This hotel caters well to families, offering books and games for children, as well as highchairs. Guests can also enjoy a complimentary continental breakfast. It is located 2.5 km from Menhadden Lane Beach. Find more child-friendly accommodations in Shelter Island Heights

For a top-tier spa experience in Shelter Island Heights, The Pridwin Hotel is an excellent choice.This 4-star hotel, boasting an impressive 9.6 rating, offers a full-service onsite spa that provides a wide range of treatments, including Swedish massage, deep tissue massage, body wraps, body scrubs, and hydrotherapy treatments. Guests can also enjoy facial treatments, manicures, pedicures, and a steam room. The Pridwin Hotel is conveniently located just 0.4 km from Crescent Beach and 1.6 km from Shelter Island Country Club, making it ideal for those who appreciate beautiful surroundings and nearby recreational activities. Guests frequently praise its beautiful and clean rooms, amazing amenities, great facilities, and delicious food. See all spa hotels in Shelter Island Heights

For hotels in Shelter Island Heights that offer complimentary breakfast, consider The Pridwin Hotel and The Rams Head Inn.The 4-star Pridwin Hotel, with an outstanding 9.6 rating, offers both free breakfast and continental breakfast. Guests frequently mention the beautiful, clean rooms, amazing amenities, and delicious food. This hotel also provides a free ferry terminal shuttle, free self-parking, and free WiFi. It boasts lovely water and ocean views and is conveniently located near Sunset Beach, just 0.9 km away, and Crescent Beach, 0.4 km away.Another option is the 4-star Rams Head Inn, rated 7.6, which also provides free breakfast and continental breakfast. This hotel offers free WiFi, free self-parking, and is situated approximately 2.5 km from Menhadden Lane Beach. Find more hotels with free breakfast in Shelter Island Heights

For top pet-friendly accommodation in Shelter Island Heights, consider The Rams Head Inn.The 4-star Rams Head Inn, with a rating of 7.6, warmly welcomes pets, specifically dogs. This charming inn offers a delightful dining experience for couples and is conveniently located just 2.5 kilometres from Menhadden Lane Beach. See more pet-friendly hotels in Shelter Island Heights

For a romantic getaway in Shelter Island Heights, couples should consider The Pridwin Hotel or The Rams Head Inn.The 4-star Pridwin Hotel, with an impressive 9.6 rating, is a beautiful option. Guests frequently praise its amazing amenities, great facilities, and delicious food. Many rooms offer lovely water or ocean views, and the hotel provides complimentary breakfast, including a continental option, and free toiletries. It is conveniently located just 0.4 km from Crescent Beach and 1.6 km from Shelter Island Country Club, making it easy to explore the surroundings.Another option is the 4-star Rams Head Inn, rated 7.6, which features couples' dining. This hotel offers complimentary continental breakfast and free toiletries, along with free self-parking. It is located 2.5 km from Menhadden Lane Beach, providing a quiet setting for a romantic escape. See all romantic hotels in Shelter Island Heights

For hotels in Shelter Island Heights near Crescent Beach, The Pridwin Hotel is an excellent choice.The 4-star Pridwin Hotel, with an impressive rating of 9.6, is located just 0.4 km from Crescent Beach. Guests consistently praise its beautiful and clean rooms, amazing amenities, and great facilities. The hotel also boasts delightful food, and its location is frequently highlighted as a major positive. Many rooms offer water or ocean views, and there is a pool available.

The best time to go to Shelter Island Heights is during the summer months, from June to September, when the weather is warm and the island is fully operational.During this period, all the island's amenities, including restaurants, shops, and recreational activities, are open and readily available. The ferry service also runs more frequently, making travel to and from the island very convenient. This time of year is superb for those looking to enjoy the beaches and outdoor activities.For those who prefer a quieter experience with pleasant weather, late spring (May) and early autumn (October) are also excellent choices. The crowds are smaller, but the weather is still generally mild enough to enjoy walking, cycling, and the island's natural beauty.