Given that Middlegate is a very small, remote settlement with limited accommodation options, the best area to stay is directly in the settlement itself, specifically near the Middlegate Station.
Middlegate Station is the heart of this historic stopping point along the Lincoln Highway. It's an iconic roadside establishment that serves as a bar, restaurant, and motel, known for its "Middlegate Monster Burger" and its collection of quirky memorabilia. The surrounding area is largely undeveloped desert landscape, so staying at the Station means you're right at the centre of any activity.
For solo travellers or couples looking for a unique, no-frills experience, staying at Middlegate Station offers an authentic taste of historic American road travel.