Find beach hotels in Shelter Island Heights, NY from CA $277

Shelter Island Heights and its attractions for beach lovers

For beach-loving travellers, Shelter Island Heights is a hidden gem offering a harmonious blend of relaxation and adventure. Start your day at Crescent Beach, a picturesque stretch perfect for sunbathing and swimming, where children can safely play in the gentle waves. Just a short stroll away, you can explore the serene grounds of the Shelter Island Historical Society, which hosts art exhibits and provides insights into the island’s charming past. For a touch of nature, head to the Mashomack Preserve, where you can hike scenic trails that lead to breathtaking views of the surrounding waters—an excellent spot for family picnics. After a day of exploration, unwind at Sunset Beach, renowned for its stunning sunset views and laid-back atmosphere, where you can sip on cocktails while your kids build sandcastles. The area boasts several quality hotels, such as The Chequit, blending modern comforts with a quaint, coastal aesthetic, ensuring your family enjoys attentive service and luxurious amenities. Staying here not only puts you within walking distance of these attractions but also allows you to immerse yourself in the local charm, making for an unforgettable beach getaway.

Find the best beach hotels and resorts in Shelter Island Heights

For those seeking a seaside escape in Shelter Island Heights, these hotels offer the perfect blend of beach access and comfortable amenities. Each hotel is designed to enhance your beach getaway experience.

The Pridwin Hotel

• Why it's great for the ultimate beach vacation spot: The Pridwin Hotel is an exquisite choice for beach enthusiasts, offering unparalleled access to a private sandy beach. With an impressive guest review rating of 9.6, guests can indulge in ocean views and exclusive beach amenities including sun loungers and umbrellas for ultimate relaxation. The hotel also features an ocean-view restaurant, allowing guests to dine while soaking in the stunning surroundings.
• Other amenities: In addition to its prime beach location, The Pridwin Hotel boasts a range of luxurious facilities including a spa with hydrotherapy treatments, a pool with sun loungers, and a fitness centre. Guests can unwind on the terrace or enjoy complimentary breakfast daily. The hotel also offers activities like billiards and has a concierge service to assist with local excursions, ensuring a memorable stay for all travelers.
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 0.1 km, Sunset Beach - 0.9 km, Shelter Island Whale's Tail - 4 km

House on Chase Creek

• Why it's great for the ultimate beach vacation spot: The House on Chase Creek is a charming and affordable retreat for those looking to enjoy the beach. With a solid review rating of 9.4, this hotel is just a short distance from nearby sandy beaches, making it a convenient option for beach lovers. Guests can enjoy a relaxed atmosphere with access to a terrace and a patio, perfect for soaking up the sun.
• Other amenities: This quaint guesthouse offers complimentary toiletries and features a fireplace for cozy evenings. Guests will appreciate the self-parking options and air conditioning for comfort. For those keen on golfing, nearby courses provide excellent recreational opportunities, making it an ideal spot for a beach and golf getaway.
• Neighborhood: The Heights
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 2.1 km, Sunset Beach - 1.9 km, Shelter Island Country Club - 0.9 km

The Chequit

• Why it's great for the ultimate beach vacation spot: The Chequit is a stylish hotel that appeals to beach lovers with its close nearby the shoreline, receiving an excellent guest review rating of 8.8. This charming hotel offers a relaxed atmosphere with beautifully decorated rooms and easy access to nearby beaches, making it an inviting choice for those looking to soak up the sun and surf.
• Other amenities: Guests will appreciate the premium bedding and access to self-parking. The hotel features a delightful garden area for relaxation and is known for its welcoming service. While it may not have direct beach amenities, the nearby beach is just a short stroll away, allowing travelers to enjoy the coastal experience without compromise.
• Neighborhood: The Heights
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 2.2 km, Sunset Beach - 1.8 km, Shelter Island Country Club - 0.9 km

Shelter Island House

• Why it's great for the ultimate beach vacation spot: Shelter Island House is a delightful mid-range option for beachgoers, a review rating of 8.4. Located conveniently near the beach, this hotel provides a comfortable stay with the added bonus of a free breakfast. Guests can enjoy easy access to the sandy shoreline while also having a relaxing space to unwind after a day in the sun.
• Other amenities: The hotel features a terrace and a garden, allowing guests to embrace the outdoors. Sheltered from the hustle and bustle, travelers can enjoy complimentary toiletries and air conditioning for a refreshing retreat. With options for dining and a concierge service, this hotel ensures that guests have everything they need for a memorable beach holiday.
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 0.8 km, Sunset Beach - 0.6 km, Shelter Island Whale's Tail - 2.7 km

West Neck Guesthouse

• Why it's great for the ultimate beach vacation spot: West Neck Guesthouse is a cozy option for those seeking a beach getaway, reflected in its review rating of 8.2. Conveniently located near the beach, this guesthouse provides a comfortable atmosphere with essential amenities for a relaxed stay, including a complimentary breakfast to start the day off right.
• Other amenities: Guests can enjoy accessible parking and a kitchenette for added convenience. The hotel also features air conditioning, a lovely garden, and daily housekeeping to ensure a comfortable experience. With its commitment to guest comfort and access to nearby beach activities, West Neck Guesthouse is a great choice for beach travelers.
• Nearby attractions: Crescent Beach - 1.1 km, Sunset Beach - 0.9 km, Shelter Island Whale's Tail - 2.2 km