Find Hotels by Independent in Sister Bay
Change your mindBook hotels with free cancellation
Be pickySearch almost a million properties worldwide
Check prices for these dates
Tonight
Sep 22 - Sep 23Tomorrow
Sep 23 - Sep 24This weekend
Sep 25 - Sep 27Next weekend
Oct 2 - Oct 4
Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in
Top Sister Bay Hotel Reviews
Open Hearth Lodge
10/10 Excellent
"We were greeted by super friendly staff and had a very enjoyable stay at open hearth!"
Sister Bay Inn
10/10 Excellent
"The staff and room cleanliness couldn't have been better. It is an older Inn but maintained well. The location to downtown Sister Bay was good (< 1 mile). One of the quietest hotels I've ever stayed at. The pictures on the website don't do it justice. Would definitely stay there again."
Gordon Lodge
8/10 Good
"Lovely property, but needs a bit of updating. The dinner senzational good, the ribeye was incredible. The breakfast mediocre at the best"
Settlement Inn & Lavender Spa
10/10 Excellent
"The Settlement Inn & Lavendar Spa is in Fish Creek, the heart of the Door County Peninsula, which made it easier to explore all the towns up and down the coast. Our room was attractive and comfortable. We had a gas fireplace in our room, which was wonderful on cool evenings. We made use of the small kitchen area and dining table for a glass of wine and late night snacks. Staff couldn't have been more helpful. The inn is on Hwy 42 but feels quiet and secluded. We hope to return to Settlement Inn sometime soon."
Bay Breeze Resort
10/10 Excellent
"Comfortable, clean rooms in great location"
DownTown Inn
10/10 Excellent
"Very clean comfortable rooms. Perfect location for walking anywhere in Sister Bay!"
Coachlite Inn
8/10 Good
"Stayed here previously and like the location. Staff is excellent. Rooms were okay albeit a bit outdated. Bed was comfortable and rooms stay relatively quiet. Would stay here again."
The Inn at Little Sister Hill
10/10 Excellent
"The property is centrally located to everything in Door County. The Inn was clean, the staff was friendly, and the property was well kept. The room itself was clean and comfortable, and we really enjoyed being on the end, ground unit. The only negative, and it’s a HUGE one, is that the mattress was horrible. I literally got about 4 hours of sleep in the two nights I stayed there. The mattress was absolutely the worst."
Updated Vintage 1938 Log Cabin – Walk to Sister Bay
10/10 Excellent
"We had a fantastic stay! The property was exactly as described—clean, comfortable, and well maintained, with everything we needed to feel right at home. The location was great, and the whole experience was smooth and relaxing from check-in to check-out.The host was friendly, responsive, and made everything incredibly easy. We really enjoyed our time here and would definitely stay again. Highly recommend!"
Explore a world of travel with Expedia
- Log Retreat w/ Private Pickleball Court in Fish Creek!
- Whispering Pines By The Bay
- Ellison Bay Hotels
- Fish Creek Hotels
- Hotels near Eagle Harbor
- Waterfront with private sandy Beach
- Cabin Rentals in Ellison Bay
- Waterfront
- Hand Hewn Log Cabin Newly Renovated
- Spa Hotels in Door County
- Cottages in Sturgeon Bay
- Door County Hotels
- Gills Rock Hotels
- Bailey's Harbor Cabin Secluded in Woods
- Stunning Studio just steps from the Bjorklunden Trail System in Baileys Harbor
- Bay Breeze Resort
- Hillside Waterfront Hotel
- The Sister Bay Getaway
- 'Rise and Shine in Door County!' Egg Harbor Haven
- Indoor Pool
- B&B in Algoma
- Waterfront Cupola House on the Bay in Tranquil Southern Door.
- Egg Harbor Condo walking distance to town. 2 bedroom
- Modern condo in scenic Egg Harbor! Heart of Door County!
- Cottages in Sister Bay
- Adorable Pet Friendly Cottage in the Heart of Ephraim! Great WiFi
- Parkwood Lodge
- Woodgrove House
- Charming garden cottage downtown Ellison Bay walking distance to lake and shops
- Forestville Hotels
- Condo 3
- Cozy Cottage in the woods of Northern Door County
- Condo 6
- Guest bedroom in Quarry House
- Hotels near Peninsula State Park
- Private
- Tiger Lily Cabin
- Nordic Lodge
- Cabin Rentals in Algoma
- Ephraim home
- Bay Breeze Cottage
- Cedar Court Inn
- Relax just minutes from the action! This dog
- Pet-Friendly Hotels in Door County
- Lake Hotels in Door County
- Wausaukee Hotels
- Brand NEW! Newly Constructed home
- Waterfront cottage 3bdrm
- Private Lakefront Paradise
- Chalets in Idlewild
- Cottages in Door County
- Hotels near Egg Harbor Fun Park
- Cottages in Idlewild
- Charming cedar log cabin nestled in the woods
- Lgbt Friendly Hotels in Door County
- Lauerman House Inn
- Fish Creek Farmhouse Peninsula Parkside Retreat
- Baileys Harbor home on North Bay
- Beechwood Cottage
- 1 Bedroom Condo w/ Kitchen at Little Sweden Resort
- Stony Shore Cabin
- Rustic DC Farmhouse Retreat
- Oconto Hotels
- Door County Waterfront Sleeps 23
- Moonlight Cabin located in Baileys Harbor
- Door County Beach House on Lake Michigan
- Lake
- Sturgeon Bay Hotels
- Clean Cozy Cottage On Waterfront Property Privacy Yet Close To Town
- Cottage on Mink River Road
- Rogers Cottage on water front Rowley’s Bay
- Lunker House By the Bay
- Houseboats in Egg Harbor
- Cottages in Algoma
- Main Street Motel
- Econo Lodge Inn & Suites Oconto
- A historic completely restored home on a five acre cherry orchard
- Cabin Rentals in Fish Creek
- Livin' the Dream in Fish Creek!
- Modern Chalet With Stunning Forest Views
- Marinette Hotels