Find hotels near Newfound Harbor Keys, Big Pine Key from CA $383

"The rooms were very clean! Views were beautiful. Pool was heated the cool days we were there. The breakfast was good and fresh. Loved the afternoon tea, hot chocolate, and coffee selections. Staff were very welcoming!"

"Our family of 10 just spent a heavenly week at Sterling Bay House and we could not love this house more! The house itself is just incredible—spacious, well organized and thought out, beautifully decorated, with so many great amenities! It truly feels like a small private resort. The location on Little Torch Key is perfect—it feels private and secluded, yet it is just a short five minute drive to the grocery store and pickleball courts. It’s also in a perfect location for a day trips to Key West or Marathon, which came in handy when we had a couple of windy days. None of us were ready to leave Sterling Bay House at the end of the week! We are also so impressed with the owners, Steve and Whitney. Steve is super responsive and helpful, and quickly fixed a couple of very minor issues that popped up. He’s also just a genuinely nice guy! We would highly recommend SBH to others, and will hopefully be returning ourselves sooner rather than later! "

"Room was very clean and comfortable. Small room but had a very comfortable small sofa and had an abundance of thick towels as well as beach towels. I was impressed with the room and check in/check out. "

"We had a great stay on Ramrod Key as 1st time snowbirders. Alvie was a great host. His house had a beautiful kitchen and bathrooms. The views were amazing. Kayaking was fun right out the back door. We walked our pup everyday in the neighborhood. Everyone was so friendly. The fenced backyard was nice too. "

"The room was beautiful; very clean and spacious. The property was in an excellent location, tucked away on a private beach and the key deer were adorable. It was an easy drive to both Marathon and Key West. Would definitely stay here again. "

"This is a very special place. You pay for the tranquility and the peace. You have a private beach all to yourself. And the deer are super friendly (yes). A great plus is you can BBQ on the beach yourself. Please fix the big fridge and make more kitchen utensils and plates and glasses available. That would make it even more positive. I would come back. "

"Lovely house, great amenities, quiet and convenient location."

"Excellent stay again. Will be back"

"The house was nice and comfortable. The spiral staircase to the beds upstairs is very narrow, designed for young children or very petite adults. Parking was also very tight in the fenced in area and your boat trailer has to be backed in for the length of Jamaica Lane. "