Find hotels near Newfound Harbor Keys, Big Pine Key from CA $307

"Within easy reach of Key West"

"Enjoyed the seating areas on both sides of our room. Quiet, except for karaoke night. Bring your own soap, they do not provide. "

"Everything was spotless, well stocked and well labeled. The Sterling Bay House exceeded our expectations. A large group of 16 gathered for a family re-union to celebrate a 70th birthday with an age range from 19 months to 86 years. Plenty of fun things to do within 40 minutes of the house."

"Too much confusion during check in process. We were on site for a hour before we were given the remedy to the “door sticking” problem - which we were unaware was even a problem - and could access the property (after being told that we were in a different room on the property and being given the access code to that room also). "

"Lots of space, clean rooms (bedrooms, bathrooms), it was nice to have laundry detergent, clean pools, loved the dock! "

"We just spent 31 nights in Jan/Feb 2026 celebrating our 48th wedding anniversary. The location was perfect for exploring all the keys. We even drove up to Miami Beach one day and was easy to get back before sunset. The location was great for day trips to Key West, getting there in less than 45 minutes. The house is on a very quiet dead-end road. There is a convenience store within 2 miles and a Winn-Dixie within 5 miles. The bird life and key deer on the beach were amazing. The heated pool was so nice and well maintained. The large washer and dryer were very nice. The Kitchen had everything we needed. The place was relaxing. Greg was very helpful and attentive. We would give this place more than 5 stars if we could."

"The house is sufficient for 2 couples, 3 in a pinch (with only 2 showers) and 2 (only) moderately sized vehicles. It was clean, kitchen sufficient for cooking. Host responsive. Exterior furniture needs some TLC but nothing that prohibited us from having a nice time. Boat dock ok for 23' boat. Decent high tide launch on the other side of island. Take your own Roku for any tv beyond basic Xfinity cable. Internet not stable some times, may just be what is available on Little Torch"

"Lovely house, great amenities, quiet and convenient location."

"Our family had an amazing time at this beautiful property in Little Torch Key! The home was spotless, well-equipped, and incredibly comfortable, especially the beds. We loved waking up to the stunning ocean views and relaxing in the constant island breeze. The fishing was fantastic, and the hosts went above and beyond, offering thoughtful recommendations for dining and local activities. they were also very responsive and made the entire experience seamless. We would absolutely stay here again. It was truly a slice of paradise!"