Find Hotels by Best Western in Newcomerstown from CA $127

"Close to downtown and restaurants"

"We so enjoyed our time at Carlisle Inn in Sugarcreek, Ohio. It was stunning inside with Amish furniture and wood throughout. It was peaceful and quiet and we loved it. "

"My husband said the breakfast was excellent and I second that motion our room was clean and comfortable. The staff was friendly and very accommodating. I definitely recommend staying at this resort. I wish we would have taken more photos."

"NEW OWNWERS WERE VERY NICE AND WELCOMING."

"Pool smelled very strong the first night. Burned our eyes. "

"Room was comfortable and clean, and breakfast was good. "

"This property holds sentimental value to me as my grandparents managed this motel years ago when a different company owned it and I spent my childhood here. I can appreciate that a lot of work has gone into repairing and fixing up the location. The new management is visibly dedicated to to ensuring that your stay is pleasant. Staff in the office and the maid service were extremely friendly and welcoming. I didn't get a chance to swim but the pool looked clean and well maintained. "

"Our stay is beautiful! I was surprised when my check in had 3 reservations when I reserved only 2 rooms and my online confirmation stated 2 rooms "

"Our room was so much more than what were expecting. "