What other neighbourhoods are similar to Bay Island?

While Bay Island offers a unique blend of waterfront living and convenient access to St. Petersburg, similar experiences can be found in the nearby neighbourhoods of Isla del Sol and Tierra Verde. Isla del Sol, located just south of St. Pete Beach, is a collection of islands known for its golf course and private beaches. It's a nicely maintained area with a mix of condominiums and single-family homes, offering a similar relaxed, island lifestyle to Bay Island. It's particularly appealing to couples looking for a tranquil escape with easy access to water activities and dining options on St. Pete Beach. Tierra Verde, further south, is another upscale island community. It's the gateway to Fort De Soto Park, offering stunning beaches and natural beauty. This neighbourhood provides a more secluded feel with larger homes and direct Gulf access for boating enthusiasts. For those who appreciate outdoor pursuits and a quiet, residential setting, Tierra Verde is an excellent choice. Families often find the proximity to Fort De Soto Park ideal for beach days and exploring nature trails.

Can I cancel my hotel reservation on Expedia?

Many Expedia hotel reservations are refundable, provided that you cancel before the hotel’s cancellation deadline – this is often within 24-48 hours of your scheduled arrival. If you have a non-refundable booking, it might still be possible to receive a refund if you cancel it within 24 hours of booking. Be sure to check your booking confirmation for the exact cancellation policy. For maximum flexibility, use our "Fully refundable property" filter during your search to find the right Bay Island hotel for you.

How can I save on a Bay Island hotel booking with Expedia?

With Expedia, you’ll unlock our lowest prices by becoming a member. It’s free and easy to join, and you can even access member perks too. Just remember to sign in to get our best prices on Bay Island hotels. Another way to save is by booking your hotel and flights together on Expedia, where bundling can lead to significant savings.

How much is the nightly rate at a Bay Island hotel?

Hotel prices in Bay Island often vary, but you can find a great deal on Expedia. Different factors affect nightly hotel rates, such as the time of year or the days of the week you want to book. To find the best deals for your stay, be flexible with your dates, and sort search results by "Price: low to high" for our cheapest rates.

10 Best Hotels in Bay Island, Siesta Key for 2026

A sunset over a body of water with a dock and palm trees.

Change your mind
Book hotels with free cancellation
Treat yourself
Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels
Sign in
Be picky
Search almost a million properties worldwide

Our top choices for Bay Island hotels

Staybridge Suites Sarasota - Bradenton Airport by IHG

10.5 km from Bay Island

Miranda Knight

CA $181 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 19 - Jul 20

Inn at the Beach

24.2 km from Bay Island

Angel

CA $266 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 9 - Aug 10

Palmetto Marriott Resort & Spa

24 km from Bay Island

Kathy

CA $275 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 27 - Jul 28

Siesta Key Beachside Villas

Siesta Key Village, 3.3 km from Bay Island

John

CA $358 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 12 - Aug 13

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Nokomis Sarasota South by IHG

21.7 km from Bay Island

HENRY

CA $162 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 9 - Aug 10

Full-size fridge, microwave, stovetop, dishwasher

Extended Stay America Premier Suites - Bradenton

16.7 km from Bay Island

Michael

CA $117 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 19 - Jul 20

Best Western Plus Ambassador Suites Venice

27 km from Bay Island

Jodi

CA $146 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 30 - Jul 31

On the beach, white sand, sun loungers, beach umbrellas

Azul Resort Siesta Key

South Village, 6.3 km from Bay Island

Alberto

CA $284 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 11 - Aug 12

Siesta Key Beach Resort and Suites

Siesta Key Village, 3.4 km from Bay Island

Denise

CA $415 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 6 - Aug 7

Hampton Inn Sarasota - I-75 Bee Ridge

10 km from Bay Island

Audrey

CA $150 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 21 - Jul 22

Compass Hotel by Margaritaville Anna Maria Sound

25.5 km from Bay Island

Holmes

CA $311 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 9 - Aug 10

Zota Beach Resort

14.5 km from Bay Island

Shaun

CA $446 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 9 - Aug 10

Carlisle Inn

6.1 km from Bay Island

Donna

CA $229 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 2 - Aug 3

Kompose Boutique Hotel

9 km from Bay Island

Polina

CA $137 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 19 - Jul 20

Holiday Inn Express Sarasota East - I-75 by IHG

10 km from Bay Island

Jarillys

CA $125 total

includes taxes & fees

Aug 2 - Aug 3

Standard Room, 2 Queen Beds, Non Smoking

Lantern Inn & Suites

12.6 km from Bay Island

Yoanis

CA $108 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 30 - Jul 31

Island Sun Inn & Suites - Historic Venice & Beach Getaway

25.9 km from Bay Island

Joan

CA $116 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 19 - Jul 20

Super 8 by Wyndham Ellenton Bradenton Area

25.7 km from Bay Island

Melanie

CA $123 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 26 - Jul 27

Outdoor pool, free cabanas, pool umbrellas

Turtle Beach Resort

10.1 km from Bay Island

Anthony

CA $562 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 15 - Jul 16

Hampton Inn Ellenton/Bradenton

26.1 km from Bay Island

Teresa

CA $182 total

includes taxes & fees

Jul 26 - Jul 27

View all properties

Where to stay in Bay Island

Find the best Bay Island areas and neighborhoods for the activities you enjoy most.

A vibrant building with a purple facade, a sign reading "Siesta," and a staircase leading to the entrance.

Siesta Key Village

Travelers to Siesta Key Village praise its stunning beaches. If you've got some more time to explore, be sure to make a stop by Siesta Key Beach and Siesta Key Farmers Market.

See properties

A large, beige colonial-style building with columns, surrounded by palm trees and dense vegetation.

South Village

While visiting South Village, you might make a stop by sights like Siesta Key Marina and Crescent Beach.

See properties

Aloha Kai

While Aloha Kai isn't home to many top sights, Siesta Key Beach and Siesta Key Beach Playground are some notable places to visit nearby.

See properties

Bailey Hall

When in Bailey Hall, you can plan a visit to Siesta Key Beach and Lido Beach, some noteworthy sights in the nearby area.

See properties

Point of Rocks

While there might not be top attractions in Point of Rocks, you can explore the larger area and discover places like Siesta Key Beach and Point of Rocks.

See properties

Top Bay Island Hotel Reviews

Compass Hotel by Margaritaville Anna Maria Sound

8/10 Good

"Really nice facility. One thing that was annoying was the outdoor pool. They shouldn't allow flotation items, such as small boats. Kids kept bumping into my wife and me, so we had to get out of the pool. If allowed have a facility member policing the pool area and hold the parents accountable for their children's actions. Teens jumping around rough housing was annoying as well."

Zota Beach Resort

10/10 Excellent

"We loved our stay at Zota! The beach was one of our favorite parts—clean, calm, and not crowded at all. The water was crystal clear and the temperature was perfect. The food was excellent, much better than we expected, and the service throughout our stay was warm and friendly. A small issue came up with our final bill, but the hotel handled it professionally, and we really appreciated their prompt help."

Hyatt Place Sarasota/Bradenton Airport

8/10 Good

"We stayed at this hotel in July 2026, and our visit happened to coincide with some major renovations. Because of the construction work, the hotel could not offer the expected infrastructure or standard experience for key areas like check-in, check-out, and the breakfast service.However, I must highlight the incredible friendliness and warmth of the staff. It was truly wonderful to see how everyone went completely out of their way and did everything in their power to ensure our stay was as comfortable as possible. That level of dedication and genuine care is something you do not see every day.Aside from the temporary construction issues, the room comfort and overall experience were quite reasonable for the price. If you are looking for a budget-friendly option with great hospitality, I highly recommend it."

Hotels in Bay Island, Siesta Key

Change your mind

Treat yourself

Be picky

Check prices for these dates

Filter by

Our top choices for Bay Island hotels

Staybridge Suites Sarasota - Bradenton Airport by IHG

Inn at the Beach

Palmetto Marriott Resort & Spa

Siesta Key Beachside Villas

Holiday Inn Express & Suites Nokomis Sarasota South by IHG

Extended Stay America Premier Suites - Bradenton

Best Western Plus Ambassador Suites Venice

Azul Resort Siesta Key

Siesta Key Beach Resort and Suites

Hampton Inn Sarasota - I-75 Bee Ridge

Compass Hotel by Margaritaville Anna Maria Sound

Zota Beach Resort

Carlisle Inn

Kompose Boutique Hotel

Holiday Inn Express Sarasota East - I-75 by IHG

Lantern Inn & Suites

Island Sun Inn & Suites - Historic Venice & Beach Getaway

Super 8 by Wyndham Ellenton Bradenton Area

Turtle Beach Resort

Hampton Inn Ellenton/Bradenton

Where to stay in Bay Island

Siesta Key Village

South Village

Aloha Kai

Bailey Hall

Point of Rocks

Top Bay Island Hotel Reviews

Compass Hotel by Margaritaville Anna Maria Sound

Frequently asked questions

Explore a world of travel with Expedia