Title: 4 Stars Hotels in Fishers Island, New York from CA $264 - Find Cheap Fishers Island Hotels With 4 Stars | Expedia.ca [Fishers Island Travel Guide](https://expedia.ca/Fishers-Island.dx1208)[Hotels in Fishers Island](https://expedia.ca/Fishers-Island-Hotels.d1208.Travel-Guide-Hotels)[Vacation Rentals in Fishers Island](https://expedia.ca/Fishers-Island-Vacation-Rentals.d1208.Travel-Guide-VacationRentals)[Flights to Fishers Island](https://expedia.ca/Cheap-Flights-To-Fishers-Island.d1208.Travel-Guide-Flights)[Fishers Island Car Rentals](https://expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Fishers-Island.d1208.Car-Rental-Guide)[Fishers Island Vacation Packages](https://expedia.ca/Fishers-Island.d1208.Destination-Travel-Guides) ![Race Rock Lighthouse, near Fisher's Island, New York.](https://images.trvl-media.com/place/1208/0e09bb50-019c-4c3e-ae1b-ca5f6943962c.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=1200&h=500&q=medium) ![](https://images.trvl-media.com/place/1208/0e09bb50-019c-4c3e-ae1b-ca5f6943962c.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=1200&h=500&q=medium) - ![](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__calendar_shield.svg) ### Change your mind Book hotels with free cancellation - ![](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__deals.svg) ### Treat yourself Sign in to save 10% or more on thousands of hotels [Sign in](https://www.expedia.ca/login) - ![](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__bed.svg) ### Be picky Search almost a million properties worldwide ## Check availability on Fishers Island 4 Star Hotels Tonight [Apr 8 - Apr 9](https://www.expedia.ca/Hotel-Search?regionId=1208&startDate=2026-04-08&endDate=2026-04-09&adults=2&star=40&rfrr=TG.LP.CheckPrices.Hotel&openPlayBack=true) Tomorrow [Apr 9 - Apr 10](https://www.expedia.ca/Hotel-Search?regionId=1208&startDate=2026-04-09&endDate=2026-04-10&adults=2&star=40&rfrr=TG.LP.CheckPrices.Hotel&openPlayBack=true) This weekend [Apr 10 - Apr 12](https://www.expedia.ca/Hotel-Search?regionId=1208&startDate=2026-04-10&endDate=2026-04-12&adults=2&star=40&rfrr=TG.LP.CheckPrices.Hotel&openPlayBack=true) Next weekend [Apr 17 - Apr 19](https://www.expedia.ca/Hotel-Search?regionId=1208&startDate=2026-04-17&endDate=2026-04-19&adults=2&star=40&rfrr=TG.LP.CheckPrices.Hotel&openPlayBack=true) ## Our top choices for Fishers Island 4-star hotels ![2 indoor pools, open 6 AM to 10 PM, cabanas (surcharge), pool umbrellas](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/900000/894300/894248/37130fc3.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Property amenity](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/900000/894300/894248/w3836h2560x4y0-b563ecb9.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Terrace/patio](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/900000/894300/894248/3c373018.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Casino](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/900000/894300/894248/60dec0f3.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Mohegan Sun [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montville-Hotels-Mohegan-Sun.h894248.Hotel-Information) Montville 9.2/10 Wonderful (2,046 reviews) "Phenomenal stay can’t wait to go back." ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Robert S [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montville-Hotels-Mohegan-Sun.h894248.Hotel-Information) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/8000000/7040000/7033800/7033726/b29cbb53.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Ocean View King](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/8000000/7040000/7033800/7033726/9241bd8b.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior detail](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/8000000/7040000/7033800/7033726/78273489.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Ocean View One Bedroom Suite](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/8000000/7040000/7033800/7033726/d3ce4464.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-Gurneys-Montauk-Resort-Seawater-Spa.h7033726.Hotel-Information) Montauk 8.4/10 Very good (753 reviews) "I had my dogs with me and they loved the beach. I loved the friendly and dog friendly staff and people. I had breakfast room serviced and it was top grade food. " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Jihyun Esther CA $672 CA $922 total includes taxes & fees Apr 22 - Apr 23 [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-Gurneys-Montauk-Resort-Seawater-Spa.h7033726.Hotel-Information) ![Bar (on property)](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/560000/559300/559246/e129fe96.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Reception](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/560000/559300/559246/w4000h2664x0y0-b9938c5e.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Sauna, steam room, body treatments, hydrotherapy, hot stone massages](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/560000/559300/559246/93ce1e29.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Room, 2 Queen Beds](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/560000/559300/559246/f6b2fc4b.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa [](https://www.expedia.ca/Groton-Hotels-Mystic-Marriott-Hotel-And-Spa.h559246.Hotel-Information) Groton 8.6/10 Excellent (1,006 reviews) "Very nice, clean good location " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Antonella CA $200 CA $264 total includes taxes & fees Apr 12 - Apr 13 [](https://www.expedia.ca/Groton-Hotels-Mystic-Marriott-Hotel-And-Spa.h559246.Hotel-Information) ![Ocean View 2 Queens](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/114000000/113580000/113578500/113578409/6944012d.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/114000000/113580000/113578500/113578409/c614d2a2.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![View from room](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/114000000/113580000/113578500/113578409/69b11154.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Outdoor pool](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/114000000/113580000/113578500/113578409/7a155d22.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Offshore Montauk [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-The-Offshore.h113578409.Hotel-Information) Montauk 9.4/10 Exceptional (122 reviews) "Hotel was beautiful !!" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Erica CA $232 CA $423 total includes taxes & fees Apr 23 - Apr 24 [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-The-Offshore.h113578409.Hotel-Information) ![2 restaurants, breakfast served](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/10000/7000/6970/c585313b.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/10000/7000/6970/d3ed50cf.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![2 restaurants, breakfast served](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/10000/7000/6970/f58691c3.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Private beach, beach towels, kayaking, fishing](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/10000/7000/6970/021137e6.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Montauk Yacht Club [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-Gurneys-Star-Island-Resort-Marina.h6970.Hotel-Information) Montauk 8.6/10 Excellent (1,000 reviews) "Wonderful hotel and location " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) FIONA CA $362 CA $571 total includes taxes & fees Apr 26 - Apr 27 [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-Gurneys-Star-Island-Resort-Marina.h6970.Hotel-Information) ![View from room](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/17000000/16550000/16544700/16544673/77f9f5ea.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Lobby lounge](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/17000000/16550000/16544700/16544673/2fdf39bf.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Reception](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/17000000/16550000/16544700/16544673/22da4a39.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/17000000/16550000/16544700/16544673/a44e62eb.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Hero Beach Club [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-Hero-Beach-Club.h16544673.Hotel-Information) Montauk 9.0/10 Wonderful (204 reviews) "Great weekend trip " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Timothy CA $248 CA $424 total includes taxes & fees Apr 30 - May 1 [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-Hero-Beach-Club.h16544673.Hotel-Information) ![Courtyard Balcony King | Courtyard view](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/16000000/15410000/15408300/15408228/5e0bc055.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior detail](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/16000000/15410000/15408300/15408228/966ffb4f.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Property grounds](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/16000000/15410000/15408300/15408228/00b9aef3.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Blackout drapes, iron/ironing board, free WiFi, bed sheets](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/16000000/15410000/15408300/15408228/268528e7.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Marram [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-Marram.h15408228.Hotel-Information) Montauk 8.8/10 Excellent (253 reviews) "Beautiful resort in a great location " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Nikki CA $284 CA $602 total includes taxes & fees Apr 26 - Apr 27 [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-Marram.h15408228.Hotel-Information) ![Room, Patio, Garden Area (Organic/Natural Breakfast Included) | Terrace/patio](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/13000000/12620000/12611300/12611288/68ae5146.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Double Room, 1 Queen Bed, Fireplace, Garden Area (Not Pet Friendly)](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/13000000/12620000/12611300/12611288/474ff4b4.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Room | Fireplace](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/13000000/12620000/12611300/12611288/57dd85da.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Room | Deep soaking bathtub](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/13000000/12620000/12611300/12611288/be02df80.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Abbey's Lantern Hill Inn [](https://www.expedia.ca/Ledyard-Hotels-Abbeys-Lantern-Hill-Inn.h12611288.Hotel-Information) Ledyard 9.6/10 Exceptional (213 reviews) "The room was a bit outdated and small, but it felt warm and cozy. Located a few minutes from the Foxwood Casino and the Outlets. The breakfast was delicious. " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Olga CA $288 CA $331 total includes taxes & fees Apr 9 - Apr 10 [](https://www.expedia.ca/Ledyard-Hotels-Abbeys-Lantern-Hill-Inn.h12611288.Hotel-Information) ![Miss Anna James Room](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/79000000/78200000/78191100/78191036/w848h631x48y3-ad11e9c5.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Point of interest](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/79000000/78200000/78191100/78191036/1891e70e.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Katharine Hepburn Room](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/79000000/78200000/78191100/78191036/20c673f8.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Point of interest](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/79000000/78200000/78191100/78191036/f09f38b4.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### James Pharmacy Bed & Breakfast [](https://www.expedia.ca/Old-Saybrook-Hotels-James-Pharmacy-Bed-Breakfast.h78191036.Hotel-Information) Old Saybrook Center 9.0/10 Wonderful (24 reviews) "Cute B&B, very nice room, check-in worked well" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Isolde CA $352 CA $390 total includes taxes & fees Apr 19 - Apr 20 [](https://www.expedia.ca/Old-Saybrook-Hotels-James-Pharmacy-Bed-Breakfast.h78191036.Hotel-Information) ![One Bedroom Condo King with Ocean view | Living area](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/119000000/118950000/118940400/118940366/fd0f941b.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![One Bedroom Condo King with Steam Shower | Living area](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/119000000/118950000/118940400/118940366/a9bb02b2.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![In-room dining](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/119000000/118950000/118940400/118940366/0ca01820.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Terrace/patio](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/119000000/118950000/118940400/118940366/804eaa5f.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Offshore Residences [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-Offshore-Residences.h118940366.Hotel-Information) Downtown Montauk 10/10 Exceptional (1 review) CA $761 CA $1,028 total includes taxes & fees Apr 14 - Apr 15 [](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-Offshore-Residences.h118940366.Hotel-Information) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/90000000/89990000/89981800/89981758/7b5c5b88.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Restaurant](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/90000000/89990000/89981800/89981758/w1170h1461x0y0-bc75bc71.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Reception](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/90000000/89990000/89981800/89981758/w1170h1164x0y1-82df79df.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Restaurant](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/90000000/89990000/89981800/89981758/602810ce.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### The Rams Head Inn [](https://www.expedia.ca/Shelter-Island-Heights-Hotels-The-Rams-Head-Inn.h89981758.Hotel-Information) Shelter Island Heights 7.6/10 Good (18 reviews) "Beautiful views and lovely service " ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Lana [](https://www.expedia.ca/Shelter-Island-Heights-Hotels-The-Rams-Head-Inn.h89981758.Hotel-Information) ![Blue Grotto](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/96000000/95010000/95001400/95001317/3ed1203d.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Blue Grotto | Private spa tub](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/96000000/95010000/95001400/95001317/43684992.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Interior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/96000000/95010000/95001400/95001317/f5a92f69.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Rosa](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/96000000/95010000/95001400/95001317/05bef180.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### The Villa Bed & Breakfast [](https://www.expedia.ca/Westerly-Hotels-The-Villa-Bed-Breakfast.h95001317.Hotel-Information) Westerly 10/10 Exceptional (19 reviews) "Wonderful stay" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Thomas [](https://www.expedia.ca/Westerly-Hotels-The-Villa-Bed-Breakfast.h95001317.Hotel-Information) ![Apartment (2 Bedrooms) | Interior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/95000000/94960000/94957900/94957876/b898e087.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Apartment (2 Bedrooms) | Interior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/95000000/94960000/94957900/94957876/687819e2.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Apartment (2 Bedrooms) | Interior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/95000000/94960000/94957900/94957876/27974fb6.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Apartment (2 Bedrooms) | Interior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/95000000/94960000/94957900/94957876/54bc2c07.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Mystic Refuge w/ Patio < 1 Mi to Downtown! [](https://www.expedia.ca/Mystic-Hotels-Mystic-Refuge-W-Patio-1-Mi-To-Downtown.h94957876.Hotel-Information) Mystic [](https://www.expedia.ca/Mystic-Hotels-Mystic-Refuge-W-Patio-1-Mi-To-Downtown.h94957876.Hotel-Information) ![Hallway](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/111000000/110170000/110169200/110169183/9fa933d9.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/111000000/110170000/110169200/110169183/9eaace75.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Daily cooked-to-order breakfast for a fee](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/111000000/110170000/110169200/110169183/w651h660x0y0-87438495.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Deluxe Room, 1 King Bed](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/111000000/110170000/110169200/110169183/34b6845b.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### DELAMAR MYSTIC [](https://www.expedia.ca/Mystic-Hotels-DELAMAR-MYSTIC.h110169183.Hotel-Information) Mystic 9.6/10 Exceptional (18 reviews) "Accommodations great, fantastic dining experience and can’t wait to come back" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) lisa [](https://www.expedia.ca/Mystic-Hotels-DELAMAR-MYSTIC.h110169183.Hotel-Information) ![Apartment (2 Bedrooms) | Interior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/95000000/94370000/94367800/94367757/8481c605.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Apartment (2 Bedrooms) | Interior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/95000000/94370000/94367800/94367757/a8a27e9c.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Apartment (2 Bedrooms) | Interior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/95000000/94370000/94367800/94367757/83e123b6.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Apartment (2 Bedrooms) | Interior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/95000000/94370000/94367800/94367757/68a29a45.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### New London Hideaway Near Beaches & Local Spots! [](https://www.expedia.ca/New-London-Hotels-New-London-Hideaway-Near-Beaches-Local-Spots.h94367757.Hotel-Information) New London 10/10 Exceptional (1 review) "Amazing stay place was super cozy and clean. Jim and Nancy were awesome and super kind! 10/10" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Christine [](https://www.expedia.ca/New-London-Hotels-New-London-Hideaway-Near-Beaches-Local-Spots.h94367757.Hotel-Information) ![Aerial view](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/32000000/31010000/31007600/31007589/4db6535f.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/32000000/31010000/31007600/31007589/bbbb0bf2.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Beach nearby](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/32000000/31010000/31007600/31007589/6809b461.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Aerial view](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/32000000/31010000/31007600/31007589/d9c11af0.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### East Hampton Art House Bed & Breakfast [](https://www.expedia.ca/East-Hampton-Hotels-East-Hampton-Art-House-Bed-Breakfast.h31007589.Hotel-Information) Clearwater Beach 9.6/10 Exceptional (65 reviews) "The hosts were really nice and the breakfast is excellent!" ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) IVAN [](https://www.expedia.ca/East-Hampton-Hotels-East-Hampton-Art-House-Bed-Breakfast.h31007589.Hotel-Information) ![Front of property - evening/night](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/11000000/10130000/10129900/10129871/f571cda6.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Interior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/11000000/10130000/10129900/10129871/10fb128f.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Pool](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/11000000/10130000/10129900/10129871/3683898d.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Standard Room, 1 Full Canopy Bed with Fireplace](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/11000000/10130000/10129900/10129871/4e21fae4.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Whitehall Mansion Inn [](https://www.expedia.ca/Mystic-Hotels-Whitehall-Mansion-Inn.h10129871.Hotel-Information) Mystic 7.8/10 Good (166 reviews) "Do not book. This property is no longer in business. We were fortunate enough to get a room next door at the Residence Inn Marriott. They were very acomodating and gave us a studio for the same price we were supposed to pay at the Whitewall. Not sure why this is still advertised as an available place to stay on Expedia." ![United States](https://a.travel-assets.com/egds/marks/flags/us.svg) Michelle [](https://www.expedia.ca/Mystic-Hotels-Whitehall-Mansion-Inn.h10129871.Hotel-Information) ![Front of property](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/36000000/35870000/35866800/35866759/58b2ae20.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Villa Lilith [](https://www.expedia.ca/East-Hampton-Hotels-Villa-Lilith.h35866759.Hotel-Information) Clearwater Beach [](https://www.expedia.ca/East-Hampton-Hotels-Villa-Lilith.h35866759.Hotel-Information) ![House, Multiple Beds (Amagansett Beachfront Beauty) | Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/68000000/67600000/67595900/67595895/8bd7bcc1.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![House, Multiple Beds (Amagansett Beachfront Beauty) | Beach](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/68000000/67600000/67595900/67595895/d7e7784c.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![House, Multiple Beds (Amagansett Beachfront Beauty) | Living room](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/68000000/67600000/67595900/67595895/5ffcb754.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![House, Multiple Beds (Amagansett Beachfront Beauty) | Exterior](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/68000000/67600000/67595900/67595895/599fb210.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### Amagansett Beachfront Beauty [](https://www.expedia.ca/Amagansett-Hotels-Amagansett-Beachfront-Beauty.h67595895.Hotel-Information) Napeague [](https://www.expedia.ca/Amagansett-Hotels-Amagansett-Beachfront-Beauty.h67595895.Hotel-Information) ![Superior Villa, Pool View | Living area](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/128000000/127690000/127680200/127680136/24fb76b2.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Superior Villa, Pool View | Pool](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/128000000/127690000/127680200/127680136/71063eb7.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Superior Villa, Pool View | Living area](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/128000000/127690000/127680200/127680136/20c11dce.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ![Superior Villa, Pool View](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/128000000/127690000/127680200/127680136/c6e7923b.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=357&h=201&p=1&q=medium) ### PinkWood PlayHouse [](https://www.expedia.ca/East-Hampton-Hotels-PinkWood-PlayHouse.h127680136.Hotel-Information) East Hampton CA $4,173 CA $4,768 total includes taxes & fees Apr 10 - Apr 11 [](https://www.expedia.ca/East-Hampton-Hotels-PinkWood-PlayHouse.h127680136.Hotel-Information) ![](https://a.travel-assets.com/pricing-claim/sparkle_dark.svg) Save an average of 15% on thousands of hotels when you're signed in [Sign in ](https://expedia.ca/user/signin?ckoflag=0&uurl=e3id%3Dredr%26rurl%3D%2F4Star-Fishers-Island-Hotels.s40-0-d1208.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels)[ Sign up, it's free ](https://expedia.ca/signup?enable_registration=true&+=&uurl=e3id%3Dredr%26rurl%3D%2F4Star-Fishers-Island-Hotels.s40-0-d1208.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) ## Learn more about Fishers Island This exclusive island retreat offers pristine beaches and the historic Henry L. Ferguson Museum showcasing local maritime heritage. Rent bicycles to explore the quiet roads or join a guided fishing charter to catch striped bass in the surrounding waters. [See all hotels in Fishers Island](https://www.expedia.ca/Hotel-Search?startDate=2026-04-22&endDate=2026-04-23&adults=2®ionId=1208) ![Race Rock Lighthouse, near Fisher's Island, New York.](https://images.trvl-media.com/place/1208/0e09bb50-019c-4c3e-ae1b-ca5f6943962c.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=899&h=573&p=1&q=high) ## Top Fishers Island Hotel Reviews ![Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/1000000/560000/559300/559246/e129fe96_y.jpg) ### Mystic Marriott Hotel and Spa 6/10 Okay "They claimed they had free breakfast and a hot tub. Both were untrue. Very disappointed " [](https://expedia.ca/Groton-Hotels-Mystic-Marriott-Hotel-And-Spa.h559246.Hotel-Information) ![Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa](https://images.trvl-media.com/lodging/8000000/7040000/7033800/7033726/b29cbb53_y.jpg) ### Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa 10/10 Excellent "WE HAD A LOVELY WEEKEND. SERVICE WAS EXCELLENT. " [](https://expedia.ca/Montauk-Hotels-Gurneys-Montauk-Resort-Seawater-Spa.h7033726.Hotel-Information) ## Find out more about Fishers Island If you’re looking for a spot with great rates, just-for-you amenities, and a world of luxurious little perks, the best 4 Stars hotels in Fishers Island are calling your name. Known for providing first-rate service in amazing locations, each of the Fishers Island 4 Stars hotels lets discerning travelers bask in an unforgettable experience. Kick back in your spacious room. Relax in the lobby’s sumptuous surroundings. Start the day with delicious room service, and then use the complimentary body care items to freshen up before you head out for the day. It’s all waiting for you at the top four star hotels in Fishers Island. Plus, when you book with Expedia.ca, you might find a cheap deal on a 4 Stars hotel in Fishers Island, New York, neighbourhoods near the most popular attractions, so you can see the sights and bask in the discounts all in one trip. Whether you’re planning a romantic retreat or simply want to experience everything the area has to offer, the top Fishers Island hotels with 4 Stars provide everything you need to unwind in style. ## Frequently asked questions ### How much does it cost to stay in a 4-star hotel in Fishers Island? > - Search for the lowest price from CA $264 ### What's the difference between 5-star and 4-star hotels in Fishers Island? ### Does Fishers Island have any 4-star all-inclusive resorts? ## Explore a world of travel with Expedia - Lodging - Flights - Packages - Cars - More ways to book - [1 Star Hotels in Hamptons ](https://www.expedia.ca/1Star-Hamptons-Hotels.s10-0-d6056452.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [2 Star Hotels in Lindenhurst ](https://www.expedia.ca/2Star-Lindenhurst-Hotels.s20-0-d183693.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [2 Star Hotels in Manorhaven ](https://www.expedia.ca/2Star-Manorhaven-Hotels.s20-0-d553248634998695724.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [2 Star Hotels in Wheatley Heights ](https://www.expedia.ca/2Star-Wheatley-Heights-Hotels.s20-0-d3000450118.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [3 Star Hotels in Flanders ](https://www.expedia.ca/3Star-Flanders-Hotels.s30-0-d3000475689.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [3 Star Hotels in Greenport ](https://www.expedia.ca/3Star-Greenport-Hotels.s30-0-d110728.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [3 Star Hotels in Jones Beach Island ](https://www.expedia.ca/3Star-Jones-Beach-Island-Hotels.s30-0-d553248635083904017.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [3 Star Hotels in Sag Harbor ](https://www.expedia.ca/3Star-Sag-Harbor-Hotels.s30-0-d154327.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [3 Star Hotels in Speonk ](https://www.expedia.ca/3Star-Speonk-Hotels.s30-0-d553248635942949979.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [4 Star Hotels in Armonk ](https://www.expedia.ca/4Star-Armonk-Hotels.s40-0-d9324.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [4 Star Hotels in Huntington Bay ](https://www.expedia.ca/4Star-Huntington-Bay-Hotels.s40-0-d553248635975876613.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [4 Star Hotels in Long Island ](https://www.expedia.ca/4Star-Long-Island-Hotels.s40-0-d602887.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [4 Star Hotels in Mahopac ](https://www.expedia.ca/4Star-Mahopac-Hotels.s40-0-d6138727.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [4 Star Hotels in Montauk ](https://www.expedia.ca/4Star-Montauk-Hotels.s40-0-d10637.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [4 Star Hotels in Rye Brook ](https://www.expedia.ca/4Star-Rye-Brook-Hotels.s40-0-d10820.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [4 Star Hotels in Sag Harbor ](https://www.expedia.ca/4Star-Sag-Harbor-Hotels.s40-0-d154327.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in Amagansett Lanes ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-Amagansett-Lanes-Amagansett-Hotels.s50-n553248635976471387-0.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in Beach Hampton ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-Beach-Hampton-Amagansett-Hotels.s50-n553248635976481908-0.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in Dix Hills ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-Dix-Hills-Hotels.s50-0-d3000448347.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in Fire Island ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-Fire-Island-Hotels.s50-0-d183671.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in Greenport ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-Greenport-Hotels.s50-0-d110728.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in Hamptons ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-Hamptons-Hotels.s50-0-d6056452.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in Indian Island County Park ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-Indian-Island-County-Park-Hotels.s50-0-d6224460.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in Jones Beach Island ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-Jones-Beach-Island-Hotels.s50-0-d553248635083904017.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in Long Island ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-Long-Island-Hotels.s50-0-d602887.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in Montauk ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-Montauk-Hotels.s50-0-d10637.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in North Fork ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-North-Fork-Hotels.s50-0-d553248635074841663.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in Oakdale ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-Oakdale-Hotels.s50-0-d9561.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in Sag Harbor ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-Sag-Harbor-Hotels.s50-0-d154327.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [5 Star Hotels in West Islip ](https://www.expedia.ca/5Star-West-Islip-Hotels.s50-0-d553248634999217120.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Boutique Hotels in Culloden Shores ](https://www.expedia.ca/Culloden-Shores-Montauk-Hotels-Boutique-Hotel.0-n553248635976472450-0-tBoutiqueHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Oceanfront Hotels in Culloden Shores ](https://www.expedia.ca/Culloden-Shores-Montauk-Hotels-Oceanfront-Hotels.0-n553248635976472450-0-tOceanfrontHotels.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Pet-Friendly Hotels in Culloden Shores ](https://www.expedia.ca/Culloden-Shores-Montauk-Hotels-Pet-Friendly-Hotel.0-n553248635976472450-0-tPetfriendlyHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Culloden Shores Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Culloden-Shores-Montauk-Hotels.0-n553248635976472450-0.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Town of East Hampton Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Destinations-In-Town-Of-East-Hampton.d553248635976437585.Hotel-Destinations) - [Hotels near Montauk ](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Airport-Hotels.0-aMTP-0.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [New York Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/New-York-Hotels.d178293.Travel-Guide-Hotels) - [Hotels near Orient Point County Park ](https://www.expedia.ca/Orient-Point-County-Park-Hotels.0-l553248621532665781-0.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Cheap Hotels in Orient Point ](https://www.expedia.ca/Orient-Point-Hotels-Cheap-Hotels.0-0-d553248635074738584-tCheapHotels.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Luxury Hotels in Orient Point ](https://www.expedia.ca/Orient-Point-Hotels-Luxury-Hotel.0-0-d553248635074738584-tLuxuryHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Orient Point Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Orient-Point-Hotels.d553248635074738584.Travel-Guide-Hotels) - [Vacation Homes in Orient Point ](https://www.expedia.ca/Orient-Point-Private-Vacation-Homes.d553248635074738584-aaPrivateVacationHomes.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Guest Houses in Town of East Hampton ](https://www.expedia.ca/Town-Of-East-Hampton-Guest-Houses.d553248635976437585-aaGuestHouses.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Flights from Montauk ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/airports/mtp/flights-from-montauk-airport) - [Flights from Hartford (BDL) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/bdl/mtp/hartford-to-montauk) - [Flights from Block Island (BID) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/bid/mtp/block-island-to-montauk) - [Flights from Boston (BOS) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/bos/mtp/boston-to-montauk) - [Flights from Buffalo (BUF) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/buf/mtp/buffalo-to-montauk) - [Flights from Columbia (CAE) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/cae/mtp/columbia-to-montauk) - [Flights from Paris (CDG) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/cdg/mtp/paris-to-montauk) - [Flights from Caldwell (CDW) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/cdw/mtp/caldwell-to-montauk) - [Flights from Chattanooga (CHA) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/cha/mtp/chattanooga-to-montauk) - [Flights from Chicago (CHI) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/chi/mtp/chicago-to-montauk) - [Flights from Charlotte (CLT) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/clt/mtp/charlotte-to-montauk) - [Flights from Washington (DCA) to Fishers Island (FID) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/dca/fid/washington-to-fishers-island) - [Flights from Detroit (DTW) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/dtw/mtp/detroit-to-montauk) - [Flights from Dublin (DUB) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/dub/mtp/dublin-to-montauk) - [Flights from New Bedford (EWB) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/ewb/mtp/new-bedford-to-montauk) - [Flights from Newark Liberty Intl. Airport (EWR) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/ewr/mtp/newark-liberty-intl-airport-to-montauk) - [Flights from Farmingdale (FRG) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/frg/mtp/farmingdale-to-montauk) - [Flights from Gaithersburg (GAI) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/gai/mtp/gaithersburg-to-montauk) - [Flights from New London (GON) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/gon/mtp/new-london-to-montauk) - [Flights from Grand Rapids (GRR) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/grr/mtp/grand-rapids-to-montauk) - [Flights from Greensboro (GSO) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/gso/mtp/greensboro-to-montauk) - [Flights from Hong Kong (HKG) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/hkg/mtp/hong-kong-to-montauk) - [Flights from White Plains (HPN) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/hpn/mtp/white-plains-to-montauk) - [Flights from Huntington (HTS) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/hts/mtp/huntington-to-montauk) - [Flights from New Haven (HVN) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/hvn/mtp/new-haven-to-montauk) - [Flights from Niagara Falls (IAG) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/iag/mtp/niagara-falls-to-montauk) - [Flights from Islip (ISP) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/isp/mtp/islip-to-montauk) - [Flights from New York (JFK) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/jfk/mtp/new-york-to-montauk) - [Flights from New York (LGA) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/lga/mtp/new-york-to-montauk) - [Flights from Montego Bay (MBJ) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/mbj/mtp/montego-bay-to-montauk) - [Flights from Mexico City (MEX) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/mex/mtp/mexico-city-to-montauk) - [Flights from Manchester (MHT) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/mht/mtp/manchester-to-montauk) - [Flights from Miami (MIA) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/mia/mtp/miami-to-montauk) - [Flights from Minneapolis (MSP) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/msp/mtp/minneapolis-to-montauk) - [Flights from Vineyard Haven (MVY) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/mvy/mtp/vineyard-haven-to-montauk) - [Flights from Newport (NPT) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/npt/mtp/newport-to-montauk) - [Flights from New York (NYC) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/nyc/mtp/new-york-to-montauk) - [Flights from Chicago (ORD) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/ord/mtp/chicago-to-montauk) - [Flights from Providence (PVD) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/pvd/mtp/providence-to-montauk) - [Flights from State College (SCE) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/sce/mtp/state-college-to-montauk) - [Flights from Louisville (SDF) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/sdf/mtp/louisville-to-montauk) - [Flights from San Francisco (SFO) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/sfo/mtp/san-francisco-to-montauk) - [Flights from Shanghai (SHA) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/sha/mtp/shanghai-to-montauk) - [Flights from Singapore (SIN) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/sin/mtp/singapore-to-montauk) - [Flights from Salt Lake City (SLC) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/slc/mtp/salt-lake-city-to-montauk) - [Flights from Orange County (SNA) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/sna/mtp/orange-county-to-montauk) - [Flights from Newburgh (SWF) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/swf/mtp/newburgh-to-montauk) - [Flights from Syracuse (SYR) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/syr/mtp/syracuse-to-montauk) - [Flights from Teterboro (TEB) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/teb/mtp/teterboro-to-montauk) - [Flights from Trenton (TTN) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/ttn/mtp/trenton-to-montauk) - [Flights from Westerly (WST) to Montauk (MTP) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/wst/mtp/westerly-to-montauk) - [Flights from Toronto (YYZ) to New York (NYC) ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/yyz/nyc/toronto-to-new-york) - [Gin Beach ](https://www.expedia.ca/Gin-Beach-Montauk.d6326886.Vacation-Attraction) - [Visit Culloden Shores ](https://www.expedia.ca/Montauk-Culloden-Shores.dx553248635976472450) - [Rental cars Montauk airport ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Montauk.d6024703.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rentals near Orient Point County Park ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Orient-Point-County-Park.d553248621532665781.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Hertz Rental Cars in Montauk ](https://www.expedia.ca/Hertz-Car-Rentals-In-Montauk.d6024703-c40.Car-Rental-Guide-Suppliers) - [Book 4 Star Hotels in Fishers Island on Expedia.com ](https://www.expedia.com/4Star-Fishers-Island-Hotels.s40-0-d1208.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels)