Search Put-in-Bay Cottage Rentals from CA $327

"Absolutely loved staying here. Great location and the host is fast at getting back with you. Even though it says it in the description, wish it had sheets and towels as our group was coming from many different states with limited room to pack extra things that the bnb didn’t provide. Otherwise great place to stay at!"

"My family thoroughly enjoyed our stay at the cottage. It was well-equipped and conveniently located a short walk from the lake, downtown, and Hoover Auditorium. The air conditioning worked great on hot and humid days and on more pleasant days we especially enjoyed relaxing on the front porch. We would definitely stay there again."

"We stayed 2 nights to celebrate my husbands birthday & we both had a great time. Will definitely be back."

"This property is just what was advertised. But, the view I don’t remember it being talked about the way I feel it should be. The view is absolutely beautiful. You are like 15 yards (if that) from Lake Erie."

"House was super cute! Just perfect for a short stay! Communication with host was great I hate renting from management companies it’s not as personal.. would definitely recommend! Only suggestion would be to stock a little bit more for functionality."

"We came out for a baseball tournament in Castalia. This Cozy Cottage was 4.5 miles from the field. It is very close to the lake, it is clean and cozy. The owners have it stocked with about everything you need, which means, I didnt have to run to the store for necessities. We would definitely stay again."

"It was a nice place with new appliances and very clean."

"Nice quiet place"

"We stayed here last year, location was decent and the house is roomy and like the fact that there are many beds. The kitchen sink drained very slowly on the right (garbage disposal side) it also backed up when we ran the dishwasher then went down. The dishwasher did not seem to wash the dishes very well. Also it seemed like something was leaking down below, a couple of things were wet but not real bad. The TV remote was no where to be found, used the one from the upstairs which turned on two...

"My husband and I along with our two boys ages 7 & 4, absolutely LOVED this place! Boys are already asking to go back! We were just close enough to all the activities we wanted to do. Also right across from us is a nice view of the lake. The house is well kept and very clean. The sunroom was our favorite room in the house it has a pinball machine radio mini fridge games and lots of toys for the kids. Great communication with the host as well and we loved Bootsy the neighbors cat! Great quiet...

"Property was good location, clse to the lake on southeast side of the island. House was spacious with plenty of room for all 8 guests. Very nice bar area. Exterior of the house needs cleaned with a few repairs needed. Front of house has no shade in afternoon, but we took our own pop-up. Golf cart was not available which would have made location more enjoyable to view neighborhood. Got to see family of foxes roaming around but no issues with them other than chewed flip-flop left outside over...

"You can’t beat this gorgeous location, surrounded by calm soothing waters of Sandusky Bay. The cottage is very well appointed with spices and nice utensils. We will definitely be back, next year or sooner!"

"We loved staying here! The house is perfect! The hot tub was perfect after a long day on Put-In-Bay! The hosts are the nicest and are just a phone call away if you need them :) Highly recommend!"

"We accepted the fact that we booked this condo with nothing to do on this island. This particular condo was janky. The overall layout and view at this building is great. I paid a hefty cleaning fee to stay here too. The entire space smelled like undiluted cleaner when we walked in. But oddly, nothing was clean. We tried to air it out, but there were holes all over the screen to the balcony. So it was bugs all night or the smell. The towels reeked; like they were washed without soap and left in...

"Absolutely loved staying here. Great location and the host is fast at getting back with you. Even though it says it in the description, wish it had sheets and towels as our group was coming from many different states with limited room to pack extra things that the bnb didn’t provide. Otherwise great place to stay at!"

"Kitchen and dishes were filthy and had some kind of gunk in the sink/glasses. Dirty balcony and sheets."