Verified review
2/10 Terrible
Matthew M.
Jun 5, 2026
Disliked: Cleanliness, check-in, communication, location, listing accuracy
Not recommended. No mini fridge, no microwave, smallest TV ever, dirty, falling apart . I have visited Put-in-Bay 3 times . The first 2 times I stayed at the Put-in-Bay resort and conference center which is way better. This hotel is the worst. The sink was blocked. They came up and removed the stopper, then insects came in and out. Toilet seat was dirty on the sides upon arrival. Toilet is old and the seat bangs loud when you close it. There were insects on the bathroom door. There is no tub. Old shower with mold and a door that doesn’t close properly. The shower faucet is on the wrong side. The shower head is old and can’t be adjusted. There is no place to hang the towels, not even one. The night light is broken and very dusty. The AC was super loud. The bed was old and not comfortable. The bathroom wall has cracks. There is no breakfast and no room service. No microwave and no Mini fridge. No coffee maker. No coffee, tea, or anything. If you request tea in the lobby, that charge 5 for a small cup. No gym. Not even a phone in the room in case you need to call front desk. You can hear people outside talking and waking. You hear people walking on the upper level. The pool was empty although other hotels had open pool. The hot tub was empty the first 2 days. It was raining and they didn’t have any umbrellas. The tiki bar was closed the first 2 days. The view is good but ultimately if I just want the view I could camp out. There is a good caping place on the island.
Stayed 3 nights in May 2026