Title: Car Rental Plum Island - Expedia.ca [Plum Island Travel Guide](https://expedia.ca/Plum-Island.dx553248635976195797)[Hotels in Plum Island](https://expedia.ca/Plum-Island-Hotels.d553248635976195797.Travel-Guide-Hotels)[Flights to Plum Island](https://expedia.ca/Cheap-Flights-To-Plum-Island.d553248635976195797.Travel-Guide-Flights)[Plum Island Vacation Packages](https://expedia.ca/Plum-Island.d553248635976195797.Destination-Travel-Guides) ![](https://images.trvl-media.com/place/8863/4262853d-d3e6-4193-8042-2f6e7c23f4d1.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=1200&h=300&q=medium) # Plum Island Car Rental ## Search and Compare from Car Companies in Plum Island Photo by Tray ## Featured car rental suppliers Compare from agencies ![car supplier logos](https://forever.travel-assets.com/flex/flexmanager/images/2022/05/16/BEXCA-car-suppliers-logo-desktop.jpg) - ![protection illustration](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__protection.svg) ### Change your mind Penalty-free cancellation on many/select car rentals - ![trophy illustration](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__trophy.svg) ### Treat yourself Members save 10% or more on over 1 million car rentals - ![package illustration](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__package.svg) ### Shop smart Compare car suppliers to unlock big savings ## Top Car Deals in Plum Island \* Price found within the past 6 days. Click for updated prices. ### Economy Chevrolet Spark or similar - 4 people Plum Island, New Jersey, USA ![Chevrolet Spark](//images.trvl-media.com/media/content/shared/images/car/Common_90X50/US_EC.png) [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&locn=Plum%20Island,%20New%20Jersey,%20United%20States%20of%20America&dpln=553248635976195797&date1=02/01/2026&date2=04/01/2026&crfrr=defaultFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22economy%22]) ### Compact Ford Focus or similar - 4 people Plum Island, New Jersey, USA ![Ford Focus](//images.trvl-media.com/media/content/shared/images/car/Common_90X50/US_CC.png) [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&locn=Plum%20Island,%20New%20Jersey,%20United%20States%20of%20America&dpln=553248635976195797&date1=02/01/2026&date2=04/01/2026&crfrr=defaultFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22compact%22]) ### Midsize Toyota Corolla or similar - 5 people Plum Island, New Jersey, USA ![Toyota Corolla](//images.trvl-media.com/media/content/shared/images/car/Common_90X50/US_IC.png) [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&locn=Plum%20Island,%20New%20Jersey,%20United%20States%20of%20America&dpln=553248635976195797&date1=02/01/2026&date2=04/01/2026&crfrr=defaultFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22midsize%22]) ### SUV Jeep Compass or similar - 5 people Plum Island, New Jersey, USA ![Jeep Compass](//images.trvl-media.com/media/content/shared/images/car/Common_90X50/US_SF.png) [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&locn=Plum%20Island,%20New%20Jersey,%20United%20States%20of%20America&dpln=553248635976195797&date1=02/01/2026&date2=04/01/2026&crfrr=defaultFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22suv%22]) ### Don't see what you're looking for? See all car rentals in Plum Island [View all cars](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&locn=Plum%20Island,%20New%20Jersey,%20United%20States%20of%20America&dpln=553248635976195797&date1=02/01/2026&date2=04/01/2026&crfrr=defaultFlex&SearchType=Place) ## Frequently asked questions ### What happens if I need to cancel my Plum Island car reservation? ### How do I find the best car rental deals in Plum Island with Expedia? ### How old do you have to be to rent a car in Plum Island? ### What do you need to rent a car in Plum Island? ### Can I rent a car for a month or longer in Plum Island? ### Where can I find a Plum Island car rental if I am younger than 25? ## Car Rental Information | Popular car types: | [SUV](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/b/car-rental/suv?rfrr=car.table.SUV), [Full Size](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/b/car-rental/fullsize?rfrr=car.table.FullSize), [Economy](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/b/car-rental/economy?rfrr=car.table.Economy) | | -------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | Car suppliers available: | | | Our best deal of the day: | | | Our second best deal of the day: | | | Our third best deal of the day: | | | From the airport to your hotel: | [Airport Transportation](https://www.expedia.ca/ground-transfers?rfrr=car.table.AirportTransportation) | ## Explore a world of travel with Expedia - Lodging - Flights - Packages - Cars - [Apartments in Atlantic Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Atlantic-Highlands-Apartments.d6047083-aaApartments.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Guest Houses in Atlantic Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Atlantic-Highlands-Guest-Houses.d6047083-aaGuestHouses.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Beach Hotel Hotels in Atlantic Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Atlantic-Highlands-Hotels-Beach-Hotel.0-0-d6047083-tBeachHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Cheap Hotels in Atlantic Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Atlantic-Highlands-Hotels-Cheap-Hotels.0-0-d6047083-tCheapHotels.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Hotels with Kitchenettes in Atlantic Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Atlantic-Highlands-Hotels-Hotels-With-Kitchenettes.0-0-d6047083-tHotelswithKitchenettes.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Pet-Friendly Hotels in Atlantic Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Atlantic-Highlands-Hotels-Pet-Friendly-Hotel.0-0-d6047083-tPetfriendlyHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Atlantic Highlands Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Atlantic-Highlands-Hotels.d6047083.Travel-Guide-Hotels) - [Aparthotels in Fair Haven ](https://www.expedia.ca/Fair-Haven-Apart-Hotels.d553248634999059931-aaApartHotels.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Apartments in Fair Haven ](https://www.expedia.ca/Fair-Haven-Apartments.d553248634999059931-aaApartments.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [B&B in Fair Haven ](https://www.expedia.ca/Fair-Haven-Bed-And-Breakfast.d553248634999059931-aaBedAndBreakfast.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Fair Haven Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Fair-Haven-Hotels.d553248634999059931.Travel-Guide-Hotels) - [Resorts in Fair Haven ](https://www.expedia.ca/Fair-Haven-Resort-Hotels.d553248634999059931-aaResortHotels.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Farmstay in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Agritourism.d6046724-aaAgritourism.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [B&B in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Bed-And-Breakfast.d6046724-aaBedAndBreakfast.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Castles in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Castles.d6046724-aaCastles.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Chalets in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Chalets.d6046724-aaChalets.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Guest Houses in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Guest-Houses.d6046724-aaGuestHouses.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Adults Only Resorts & in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Hotels-Adults-Only-Resorts.0-0-d6046724-tAdultsOnlyResorts.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Beach Hotel Hotels in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Hotels-Beach-Hotel.0-0-d6046724-tBeachHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Boutique Hotels in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Hotels-Boutique-Hotel.0-0-d6046724-tBoutiqueHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Golf Hotels in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Hotels-Golf-Hotel.0-0-d6046724-tGolfHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Hotels with Early Check-in in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Hotels-Hotel-With-Early-Check-In.0-0-d6046724-thotelwithearlycheckin.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Winery Hotels in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Hotels-Winery-Hotel.0-0-d6046724-tWineryHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Highlands Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Hotels.d6046724.Travel-Guide-Hotels) - [Inns in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Inns.d6046724-aaInns.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Lodges in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Lodges.d6046724-aaLodges.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Ranches in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Ranches.d6046724-aaRanches.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Resorts in Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Highlands-Resort-Hotels.d6046724-aaResortHotels.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Aparthotels in Leonardo ](https://www.expedia.ca/Leonardo-Apart-Hotels.d3000447338-aaApartHotels.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [B&B in Leonardo ](https://www.expedia.ca/Leonardo-Bed-And-Breakfast.d3000447338-aaBedAndBreakfast.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Castles in Leonardo ](https://www.expedia.ca/Leonardo-Castles.d3000447338-aaCastles.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Guest Houses in Leonardo ](https://www.expedia.ca/Leonardo-Guest-Houses.d3000447338-aaGuestHouses.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Hostels in Leonardo ](https://www.expedia.ca/Leonardo-Hostels.d3000447338-aaHostels.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Cheap Hotels in Leonardo ](https://www.expedia.ca/Leonardo-Hotels-Cheap-Hotels.0-0-d3000447338-tCheapHotels.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Leonardo Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Leonardo-Hotels.d3000447338.Travel-Guide-Hotels) - [Inns in Leonardo ](https://www.expedia.ca/Leonardo-Inns.d3000447338-aaInns.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [B&B in Middletown ](https://www.expedia.ca/Middletown-Bed-And-Breakfast.d8863-aaBedAndBreakfast.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Beach Hotel Hotels in Middletown ](https://www.expedia.ca/Middletown-Hotels-Beach-Hotel.0-0-d8863-tBeachHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Boutique Hotels in Middletown ](https://www.expedia.ca/Middletown-Hotels-Boutique-Hotel.0-0-d8863-tBoutiqueHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Hotels with Free Parking in Middletown ](https://www.expedia.ca/Middletown-Hotels-Hotels-With-Free-Parking.0-0-d8863-tHotelswithFreeParking.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Pet-Friendly Hotels in Middletown ](https://www.expedia.ca/Middletown-Hotels-Pet-Friendly-Hotel.0-0-d8863-tPetfriendlyHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Middletown Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Middletown-Hotels.d8863.Travel-Guide-Hotels) - [Inns in Middletown ](https://www.expedia.ca/Middletown-Inns.d8863-aaInns.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Hotels near Monmouth County Beach ](https://www.expedia.ca/Monmouth-County-Beach-Hotels.0-l692114433112334336-0.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Navesink Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Navesink-Atlantic-Highlands-Hotels.0-n553248635976471228-0.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Beach Hotel Hotels in Port Monmouth ](https://www.expedia.ca/Port-Monmouth-New-Jersey-Hotels-Beach-Hotel.0-n553248635976007392-0-tBeachHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Port Monmouth Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Port-Monmouth-New-Jersey-Hotels.0-n553248635976007392-0.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Castles in Rumson ](https://www.expedia.ca/Rumson-Castles.d3000447518-aaCastles.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Cheap Hotels in Rumson ](https://www.expedia.ca/Rumson-Hotels-Cheap-Hotels.0-0-d3000447518-tCheapHotels.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Luxury Hotels in Rumson ](https://www.expedia.ca/Rumson-Hotels-Luxury-Hotel.0-0-d3000447518-tLuxuryHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Rumson Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Rumson-Hotels.d3000447518.Travel-Guide-Hotels) - [Hotels near Sandy Hook Gateway National Recreation Area ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sandy-Hook-Gateway-National-Recreation-Area-Hotels.0-l6127255-0.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Beach Hotel Hotels in Sandy Hook ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sandy-Hook-Highlands-Hotels-Beach-Hotel.0-n553248635074842955-0-tBeachHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Golf Hotels in Sandy Hook ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sandy-Hook-Highlands-Hotels-Golf-Hotel.0-n553248635074842955-0-tGolfHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Sandy Hook Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sandy-Hook-Highlands-Hotels.0-n553248635074842955-0.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Hotels near Sandy Hook Lighthouse ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sandy-Hook-Lighthouse-Hotels.0-l6093519-0.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [B&B in Sea Bright ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sea-Bright-Bed-And-Breakfast.d3000447524-aaBedAndBreakfast.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Beach Hotel Hotels in Sea Bright ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sea-Bright-Hotels-Beach-Hotel.0-0-d3000447524-tBeachHotel.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Cheap Hotels in Sea Bright ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sea-Bright-Hotels-Cheap-Hotels.0-0-d3000447524-tCheapHotels.Travel-Guide-Filter-Hotels) - [Sea Bright Hotels ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sea-Bright-Hotels.d3000447524.Travel-Guide-Hotels) - [Inns in Sea Bright ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sea-Bright-Inns.d3000447524-aaInns.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Lodges in Sea Bright ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sea-Bright-Lodges.d3000447524-aaLodges.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Motels in Sea Bright ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sea-Bright-Motels.d3000447524-aaMotels.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Resorts in Sea Bright ](https://www.expedia.ca/Sea-Bright-Resort-Hotels.d3000447524-aaResortHotels.Travel-Guide-Accommodation) - [Flights from Fair Haven ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/553248634999059931/flights-from-fair-haven) - [Flights from Middletown ](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/flights/8863/flights-from-middletown) - [Visit Atlantic Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Atlantic-Highlands.dx6047083) - [Visit Keansburg ](https://www.expedia.ca/Keansburg.dx6355149) - [Leonardo Vacations ](https://www.expedia.ca/Leonardo.d3000447338.Destination-Travel-Guides) - [Budget Rental Cars in Atlantic Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Budget-Car-Rentals-In-Atlantic-Highlands.d6047083-c39.Car-Rental-Guide-Suppliers) - [Car rental Asbury Park ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Asbury-Park.d6159.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Bayonne ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Bayonne.d6273.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rentals near Bergen ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Bergen.d6142071.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rentals near Cape Liberty Cruise Port ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Cape-Liberty-Cruise-Port.d6333883.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Carteret ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Carteret.d7275.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rentals near Central Railroad of New Jersey Terminal ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Central-Railroad-Of-New-Jersey-Terminal.d6262077.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Colts Neck ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Colts-Neck.d55644.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rentals near Downtown Jersey City ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Downtown-Jersey-City.d6056836.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Eatontown ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Eatontown.d7810.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Elizabeth ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Elizabeth.d7830.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Fords ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Fords.d6048258.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rentals near Greenville ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Greenville.d553248635976480029.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Hazlet ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Hazlet.d8319.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Highlands ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Highlands.d6046724.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rentals near Holland Tunnel ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Holland-Tunnel.d6183062.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Holmdel ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Holmdel.d6250933.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Iselin ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Iselin.d10098.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rentals near Jersey City ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Jersey-City.d6023404.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rentals near Journal Square ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Journal-Square.d6229383.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Linden ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Linden.d126157.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Rental cars Linden airport ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Linden.d6262065.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Long Branch ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Long-Branch.d8410.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Middletown ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Middletown.d8863.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Rental cars Newark Liberty Intl. Airport airport ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Newark-Liberty-Intl-Airport.d5396293.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Perth Amboy ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Perth-Amboy.d145083.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Rahway ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Rahway.d149302.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rentals near Red Bank - Tinton Falls ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Red-Bank-Tinton-Falls.d6025618.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Red Bank ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Red-Bank.d9599.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Tinton Falls ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Tinton-Falls.d8432.Car-Rental-Guide) - [Car rental Woodbridge ](https://www.expedia.ca/Car-Rentals-In-Woodbridge.d177733.Car-Rental-Guide) ![](https://a.travel-assets.com/mad-service/footer/bnaBanners/BEX_Footer.jpg) ## Go further with the Expedia app Save on select hotels and earn double points when you book on the app. Our app deals help you to save on trips so you can travel more and manage it all on the go. Scan the QR code with your device camera and download our app