Search Lodges in New Shoreham from CA $189

"My family booked a 2 night stay here last minute in March to have an anticipated rainy beach day by their indoor poor during a road trip. The website (still, April 2026) lists a pool as an amenity. Expedia also lists that the property has a pool. However they have NOT had a working pool in some time. We arrived in the evening so agreed to stay the first night but wanted to cancel the second day/night within the allowable time but were told by the hotel only Expedia could initiate our cancellation, which hotel manager would have to approve. The manager would not then and has not since responded to the request for cancellation and hotel has kept our payment - against the stated policy. Staff even mentioned knowing the website incorrectly lists a pool though thought it’s not a currently an amenity. Pros: front desk staff are really nice. Rooms are dated but clean and comfortable. It’s directly across from the beach."

"Business facilities were unavailable both days of stay"

"Good stay ! Great check in ! "

"Clean room. Staff was nice "

"Ocean view, quiet"

"The host is very responsive. Beautiful place. Very comfortable bed and nice kitchen and sitting area. 2 minute walk to the beach."

"Wonderful time. Very comfortable bed. "

"Old school wonder. Incredibly friendly and kind service. Loved the vintage ambience and the adorable house kitty! Great food. The host baking cookies was just such a stylish and homey touch. Loved my time here. "

"Location is perfect. "