Price: CA $159, CA $181 total, includes taxes & fees, Nov 30 - Dec 1, for Recommended hotels in Shirley
Review: We have stayed here repeatedly. It is consistently quiet, exceptionally clean and well maintained. Rooms have comfortable beds and multiple lights with variable lighting settings. Ample parking is available and the grounds are well lite., by John
Price: CA $181, CA $206 total, includes taxes & fees, Nov 29 - Nov 30, for Recommended hotels in Shirley
Review: Friendly staff, decent room, by Lara
Lowest nightly price found within the past 24 hours based on a 1 night stay for 2 adults. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply.
Stroll along the charming Main Street, where local shops and eateries showcase the town's friendly small-town vibe. For outdoor enthusiasts, nearby Fire Island National Seashore offers pristine beaches and scenic hiking trails along the Atlantic coast.
Review: The location was ideal for a stop during a road trip. The hotel was relatively clean and comfortable overall. However, the rooms facing the main road can be a little noisy, especially at night. The breakfast was quite basic, with not many options to choose from. I would have appreciated having some peanut butter or cheese available. Overall, it was a convenient place to stay for a road trip stop., by Christian, September 29, 2026, rated 10/10 Excellent
Review: I was looking for a pet-friendly spot for my little Westie, and Hotel Indigo was very welcoming. The location was ideal for the purpose of my trip and the staff were AMAZING … and the food in Bistro 72 was better than any hotel restaurants I've experienced recently! Thank you for accommodating us., by Anonymous traveller, September 18, 2019, rated 10/10 Excellent
Review: I stayed for one night with my family, the room was spacious and clean. The front desk staff were very friendly and helpful. Breakfast was varied and good. Parking was available and free. Would definitely recommend., by Sandra, September 14, 2026, rated 10/10 Excellent
Review: My stay was absolutely incredible! From the moment I arrived, Jen made me feel so welcome. After an early travel day, her warmth and kindness immediately made me feel comfortable and at home. She gave me so many great recommendations and was incredibly attentive, making everything over the last two days feel completely seamless and enjoyable. As a solo traveler, I also felt incredibly safe on the property, which was so important to me. The location is amazing and within easy walking distance of..., by Mel, October 6, 2026, rated 10/10 Excellent
Review: Quiet and peaceful hotel .Big rooms and complete amenities . Highly recommended if you wanted to explore Long Island ., by Ivana Sariah, September 3, 2026, rated 10/10 Excellent