Find Hotels with a Pool in Fishers Island, NY

"Very nice staff. Quick check in. Very clean. Convenient to highway and casino !"

"It didn’t start out great but I called the hotel staff and they changed out room and made it right. Definitely a game changer for our stay. Thank you "

"Great property "

"Clean. Its a top priortity of mine when booking a hotel. Indoor pool, heated and the pool room was heated, and clean fresh towels, changing rooms in that area, nice addition. Complimentary coffee, was great. Check in very easy. Shampoo, conditoner body wash hand soap all available for use, and they are large sizes connected to shower wall and bathroom. I would absolutely stay there agajn. Air conditioner and internet worked great, air conditioenr does turn off when it reached temp.and will.kick back on, which makes sense. So if you need the consistent noise i recommend bringing a soudn machine or using your phone if the noise on and off is an issue for you. Convenient outlets on might stands. Loved this place. We are a familt of 3, my son being 5 and first time over night at hotel. He was vwry comfortable. Property grounds are well kept. I was up around 6:30 am and enjoyed coffe, the garden and waterfall, nice place to see birds and sunrise, located "

"Clean, good value. The pool area looked a little rough"

"Such a well-run establishment. From check-in to casual restaurants to high end dining, it's just so customer friendly. "

"Reasonable accommodation in premium location. Great find"

"Clean room nice continental breakfast and nice staff"

"The room was clean and comfortable- if you take a close look you can tell it’s an older building that has been updated by all the old lumps and dents in the walls they painted over lol. Otherwise it looks very nice and is clean which is the most important. Plenty of outlets in the room and a full length mirror! The two women at the desk when I checked in were very pleasant and informative however at check out the gentlemen at the counter was sassy and seemed to not want to be bothered. I arrived at the breakfast towards the end and it was just bagels with toppings, muffins, cereal, and hard boiled eggs.. not sure if there were hot foods earlier that I missed. Overall Id stay here again."