Search Mattituck Cottage Rentals from CA $286

"Great stay & great staff!"

"We had such a wonderful one night stay at Shalom Cottage! The place was absolutely beautiful—so cozy, clean, and thoughtfully decorated. Raj, the host was truly amazing! He was kind, responsive, and made sure we had everything we needed from start to finish. We felt so welcomed and comfortable the entire time. We would definitely love to stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone! "

"Great host and property"

"Great stay. Would stay again. "

"We really enjoyed our stay here. The house has a cozy, homey feel and was a nice place to come back to after being out for the day. It was quiet, comfortable, and had a relaxed vibe that made the trip easy.The location was a big plus for us. Hammonasset Beach was only a few minutes away, and Madison center was just as close, which made it easy to grab dinner or pop out for anything we needed. The outdoor fireplace was also a really nice touch and made the evenings feel special.Overall, it was a...

"We had a wonderful stay at this cottage. It was 2 of us and 2 dogs. The property was perfect for the pups, had beautiful views of the water and walking distance to town. Very relaxing and had everything we needed for our stay. Pat was a great host and we will be back in the future!"

"Wonderful house. Immaculate with all the provisions you can hope for. Perfect location and beautifully done!"