Featured car rental suppliers
Compare from agencies
Compare car suppliers to unlock big savings, and package your flight, hotel, and car to save even more.
Members save 10% more on select hotels, cars, activities and vacation rentals. Sign up.
Enjoy maximum flexibility with penalty-free cancellation on most car rentals.
Top Car Deals in Fire Island
3-day car rental in Fire Island
Sun., May 19 - Wed., May 22
Economy
Kia Rio or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $458
total
found 9 hours ago
Sun., May 19 - Wed., May 22
Compact
Kia Soul or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $458
total
found 9 hours ago
Sun., May 19 - Wed., May 22
Midsize
Toyota Corolla or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $465
total
found 9 hours ago
Sun., May 19 - Wed., May 22
Full Size
Toyota Camry or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $480
total
found 12 hours ago
Sun., May 19 - Wed., May 22
Standard
Volkswagen Jetta or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $480
total
found 10 hours ago
Mon., May 20 - Thu., May 23
Special
EV Managers Special or similar
New York, New York, USA
CA $619
total
found 9 hours ago
Sun., May 19 - Wed., May 22
Mini Van
Chrysler Pacifica or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $677
total
found 10 hours ago
Mon., May 20 - Thu., May 23
Standard Elite Special
Ford Mustang Mach-E or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $706
total
found 9 hours ago
Thu., May 23 - Sun., May 26
Luxury
Chrysler 300 or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $736
total
found 7 hours ago
Mon., May 20 - Thu., May 23
Midsize Elite
Tesla Model 3 or similar
New York, New York, USA
CA $819
total
found 11 hours ago
Sun., May 19 - Wed., May 22
Premium SUV
Chevrolet Suburban or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $984
total
found 10 hours ago
Sun., May 19 - Wed., May 22
Premium Elite SUV
Jeep Grand Wagoneer or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $1,554
total
found 9 hours ago
2-day car rental in Fire Island
Sun., May 19 - Tue., May 21
Economy
Kia Rio or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $344
total
found 19 hours ago
Sun., May 19 - Tue., May 21
Compact
Kia Soul or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $344
total
found 19 hours ago
Sun., May 19 - Tue., May 21
Midsize
Toyota Corolla or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $349
total
found 19 hours ago
Sun., May 19 - Tue., May 21
Full Size
Toyota Camry or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $360
total
found 19 hours ago
Sun., May 19 - Tue., May 21
Standard
Volkswagen Jetta or similar
New York City, New York, USA
CA $360
total
found 19 hours ago
Mon., May 20 - Wed., May 22
Special
EV Managers Special or similar
New York, New York, USA
CA $439
total
found 2 days ago
1-day car rental in Fire Island
Wed., May 22 - Thu., May 23
Special
EV Managers Special or similar
New York, New York, USA
CA $45
total
found 8 hours ago
Tue., May 21 - Wed., May 22
Compact
Nissan Versa Note or similar
New York, New York, USA
CA $88
total
found 9 hours ago
Mon., May 20 - Tue., May 21
Full Size
Nissan Altima or similar
New York, New York, USA
CA $106
total
found 9 hours ago
Sun., May 19 - Mon., May 20
Standard
Nissan Altima or similar
New York, New York, USA
CA $113
total
found 9 hours ago
Mon., May 20 - Tue., May 21
Economy
Chevrolet Spark or similar
New York, New York, USA
CA $82
total
found 8 hours ago
Tue., May 21 - Wed., May 22
Midsize
Toyota Corolla or similar
New York, New York, USA
CA $89
total
found 8 hours ago
Frequently asked questions
Car Rental Information
Popular car types: | SUV, Full Size, Economy |
---|---|
Car suppliers available: | |
Our best deal of the day: | CA $45 |
Our second best deal of the day: | CA $82 |
Our third best deal of the day: | CA $88 |
From the airport to your hotel: | Airport Transportation |
Find Popular Airports close to Fire Island
- Car rentals at LaGuardia Airport (LGA)
- Car rentals at Stewart Intl. Airport (SWF)
- Car rentals at John F. Kennedy Intl. Airport (JFK)
- Car rentals at Liberty Intl. Airport (EWR)
- Car rentals at Republic Airport (FRG)
- Car rentals at MacArthur Airport (ISP)
- Car rentals at East Hampton Airport (HTO)
- Car rentals at Francis S. Gabreski Airport (FOK)
Car Rental Deals in Top Destinations
- Car rentals in Las Vegas
- Car rentals in New York
- Car rentals in Orlando
- Car rentals in London
- Car rentals in Paris
- Car rentals in Cancun
- Car rentals in Miami
- Car rentals in Los Angeles
- Car rentals in Rome
- Car rentals in Punta Cana
- Car rentals in Riviera Maya
- Car rentals in Barcelona
- Car rentals in San Francisco
- Car rentals in San Diego County
- Car rentals in Oahu
- Car rentals in Chicago
Car Rentals Suppliers in Fire Island
- Alamo Rent A Car car rentals in Fire Island
- Budget car rentals in Fire Island
- Enterprise car rentals in Fire Island
- Hertz car rentals in Fire Island
- Thrifty Car Rental car rentals in Fire Island
- Avis car rentals in Fire Island
- Dollar Rent A Car car rentals in Fire Island
- Sixt car rentals in Fire Island
- National car rentals in Fire Island
- Fox Rental Cars car rentals in Fire Island
- Payless car rentals in Fire Island
- Europcar car rentals in Fire Island
Find Other Car Classes in Fire Island
- Mini car rentals in Fire Island
- Economy car rentals in Fire Island
- Compact car rentals in Fire Island
- Midsize car rentals in Fire Island
- Standard car rentals in Fire Island
- Fullsize car rentals in Fire Island
- Premium car rentals in Fire Island
- Luxury car rentals in Fire Island
- Convertible car rentals in Fire Island
- Minivan car rentals in Fire Island
- Van car rentals in Fire Island
- SUV car rentals in Fire Island
- Pickup car rentals in Fire Island
- Sportscar car rentals in Fire Island
Top Hotels in Fire Island
- Hyatt Regency Long Island
- The Garden City Hotel
- Viana Hotel and Spa, Trademark Collection by Wyndham
- La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Garden City
- Long Island Marriott
- Inn at Jericho
- Hampton Inn Long Island-Brookhaven
- Hilton Garden Inn Westbury
- La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport
Expedia's Latest Trends
Hotels
Hotels in HamptonsHotels near Bills StadiumHotels near Walden Galleria MallHotels with Waterslides in Upstate New YorkAll Inclusive Resorts and Hotels in Niagara Falls - Western New YorkHotels in Upstate New YorkHotels in BrooklynRomantic Hotels in Upstate New YorkWaterpark Hotels in Niagara Falls - Western New YorkHotels with Free Airport Shuttle in Niagara Falls - Western New YorkManhattan hotelsMidtown hotelsHotels in Grand IslandHotels in Long IslandCheap Hotels in ManhattanHotels in Finger Lakes RegionHotels in Adirondack RegionHotels in Niagara Falls - Western New YorkLuxury Hotels in St. Lawrence SeawaySoHo hotels
Flights