New York Mills Vacation Rentals

"Absolutely loved this place! My partner and I were road-tripping back to MA from WY and found this cute spot our first night driving. The view is amazing from the lake and definitely worth the stay even for one night. I wish we could've been there for longer. They left snacks in our room which was super helpful given we were so hungry from a long day's drive!!! 10/10 recommend!!!! "

"Wonderful desk staff"

"Very impressed with our stay here. Everything was ready to go when we got there and was as advertised! Nice quiet place on the hillside, right over the lake. We were able to catch some bass and other fish right off the dock. It was a bit chilly and rainy for part of it but they continuously provided fire wood so that we could keep the fire going throughout and the heat in the camper worked great! The property managers were a dream to deal with! Stopped down in the mornings to refill the water tank and empty the sewer tank. Very friendly, but not overbearing. I appreciated that very much! The privacy was great as well. All the other reviews were spot on (up until this point)! The s'mores stuff left behind was great and the almost nightly visits from an Orange cat (I called Garfield, lol) were nice as well. Came through about 9-10pm and stopped to say hi for a moment, then continued on.😁 A couple of notes for future guests: the lake is private, so that means no boat access. This was not a problem at all because of all the great lakes around. I did bring my boat and foolishly didn't check the driveway before pulling into it. There is very little turn around space when you get down to the bottom. I had to unhook the boat and turn it around by hand. It was a job to say the least. So when we got back from fishing the second day, it was just easier to back the boat down the driveway. Again these are just notes, no issues! Would definitely stay here again!! 10 out of 10!!"

"We were there for our granddaughter graduation. This was a beautiful location for our family thanks so much"

"The cabin was perfect for our family weekend getaway. So welcoming and accommodating with thoughtful extras for us. Loved to see the sunrise over the lake."

"We loved it. The kitchen is beautiful and I found a bunch of morels in the area. Deans was super nice and thoughtful"

"Great stay! Highly recommend!"

"Lots of amenities to enjoy…very well kept"

"It was refreshing to rent a hotel and feel safe and the cleanliness was amazing. The staff was amazing."