Title: Fire Island Pines Car Rental, NY - Search & Compare - Expedia.ca​ [Fire Island Pines Travel Guide](https://expedia.ca/Fire-Island-Pines.dx553248635074843926)[Hotels in Fire Island Pines](https://expedia.ca/Fire-Island-Pines-Hotels.d553248635074843926.Travel-Guide-Hotels)[Flights to Fire Island Pines](https://expedia.ca/Cheap-Flights-To-Fire-Island-Pines.d553248635074843926.Travel-Guide-Flights)[Fire Island Pines Vacation Packages](https://expedia.ca/Fire-Island-Pines.d553248635074843926.Destination-Travel-Guides) ![](https://images.trvl-media.com/place/553248635074843926/8f9bd9f0-71ad-4250-8a06-93f67664d3f0.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=1200&h=300&q=medium) # Fire Island Pines Car Rental ## Search and Compare from Car Companies in Fire Island Pines ## Featured car rental suppliers Compare from agencies ![car supplier logos](https://forever.travel-assets.com/flex/flexmanager/images/2022/05/16/BEXCA-car-suppliers-logo-desktop.jpg) - ![protection illustration](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__protection.svg) ### Change your mind Penalty-free cancellation on many/select car rentals - ![trophy illustration](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__trophy.svg) ### Treat yourself Members save 10% or more on over 1 million car rentals - ![package illustration](https://a.travel-assets.com/travel-assets-manager/pictogram-bex/light__package.svg) ### Shop smart Compare car suppliers to unlock big savings ## Top Car Deals in Fire Island Pines \* Price found within the past 6 days. Click for updated prices. Mon, Feb 23 - Tue, Feb 24 ### Economy Ford Fiesta or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Ace](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/AC.png) Newark, New York, USA ![Ford Fiesta](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/2/74fbe5d7-a799-48aa-8ad0-7d3622573427.jpg) #### CA $98 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.698330&olon=-74.187710&date1=23/02/2026&date2=24/02/2026&pprfrr=49.31&tprfrr=98.25&cvrfrr=AC&ctrfrr=EC&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22economy%22]) Mon, Feb 23 - Tue, Feb 24 ### Midsize Toyota Corolla or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Budget](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZD.png) Newark, New York, USA ![Toyota Corolla](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/39/7de108ae-c097-4d80-8d72-055bcc69cedd.jpg) #### CA $91 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.686730&olon=-74.191090&date1=23/02/2026&date2=24/02/2026&pprfrr=49.58&tprfrr=90.67&cvrfrr=ZD&ctrfrr=IC&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22midsize%22]) Mon, Feb 23 - Tue, Feb 24 ### Standard Volkswagen Jetta or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Budget](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZD.png) Newark, New York, USA ![Volkswagen Jetta](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/39/3404ce5f-b103-4d29-910a-9b5d064cebb0.jpg) #### CA $93 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.686730&olon=-74.191090&date1=23/02/2026&date2=24/02/2026&pprfrr=51.77&tprfrr=93.4&cvrfrr=ZD&ctrfrr=SC&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22standard%22]) Mon, Feb 23 - Tue, Feb 24 ### Full Size Toyota Camry or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Budget](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZD.png) Newark, New York, USA ![Toyota Camry](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/39/4bdc7515-df09-4702-8fda-c9522c95cf21.jpg) #### CA $93 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.686730&olon=-74.191090&date1=23/02/2026&date2=24/02/2026&pprfrr=51.77&tprfrr=93.4&cvrfrr=ZD&ctrfrr=FC&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22fullsize%22]) Mon, Feb 23 - Tue, Feb 24 ### Mini Van Chrysler Pacifica or similar - 7 people - Unlimited mileage ![Budget](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZD.png) Newark, New York, USA ![Chrysler Pacifica](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/39/e7400a6a-2473-474b-9d79-35076bd3a23f.jpg) #### CA $97 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.686730&olon=-74.191090&date1=23/02/2026&date2=24/02/2026&pprfrr=54.79&tprfrr=97.13&cvrfrr=ZD&ctrfrr=MV&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22minivan%22]) Mon, Feb 23 - Tue, Feb 24 ### Compact SUV Chevrolet Trax or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Thrifty](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZT.png) Newark, New York, USA ![Chevrolet Trax](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/45/e5049869-5354-4b79-b9ed-1c3a5a8f0f87.jpg) #### CA $66 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.686660&olon=-74.193670&date1=23/02/2026&date2=24/02/2026&pprfrr=65.72&tprfrr=65.72&cvrfrr=ZT&ctrfrr=CF&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22suv%22]) Mon, Feb 23 - Tue, Feb 24 ### Special Dealers Choice or similar - 4 people - Unlimited mileage ![Ace](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/AC.png) Newark, New York, USA ![Dealers Choice](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/2/fca70811-adb0-4bb1-83ef-4fa130b3ebf5.jpg) #### CA $126 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.698330&olon=-74.187710&date1=23/02/2026&date2=24/02/2026&pprfrr=70.48&tprfrr=126.45&cvrfrr=AC&ctrfrr=XX&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22other%22]) Mon, Feb 23 - Tue, Feb 24 ### Premium SUV Ford Expedition Max or similar - 7 people - Unlimited mileage ![Budget](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZD.png) Newark, New York, USA ![Ford Expedition Max](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/39/14bbb639-9484-430f-b983-ee2957aba550.jpg) #### CA $129 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.686730&olon=-74.191090&date1=23/02/2026&date2=24/02/2026&pprfrr=80.26&tprfrr=128.74&cvrfrr=ZD&ctrfrr=PF&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22suv%22]) Mon, Feb 23 - Tue, Feb 24 ### Luxury Cadillac CT5 or similar - 5 people - Unlimited mileage ![Budget](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/logos/ZD.png) Newark, New York, USA ![Cadillac CT5](//mediaim.expedia.com/cars/39/2bd5c014-4d39-4590-bba3-eb45924b7c90.jpg) #### CA $246 total found 2 days ago [](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&olat=40.686730&olon=-74.191090&date1=23/02/2026&date2=24/02/2026&pprfrr=174.77&tprfrr=245.94&cvrfrr=ZD&ctrfrr=LC&crfrr=pricefeedResponseFlex&SearchType=Place&selCC=[%22luxury%22]) ### Don't see what you're looking for? See all car rentals in Fire Island Pines [View all cars](https://expedia.ca/carsearch?paandi=true&fdrp=1&styp=2&dagv=1&subm=1&locn=Fire%20Island%20Pines,%20New%20York,%20United%20States%20of%20America&dpln=553248635074843926&date1=28/02/2026&date2=02/03/2026&crfrr=defaultFlex&SearchType=Place) Lowest prices found within the past 2 days. Prices and availability subject to change. Additional terms may apply. ![](https://forever.travel-assets.com/flex/flexmanager/images/2026/02/06/expedia-sale-2026-desktop-us-ca.jpg?impolicy=fcrop&w=1400&h=600&q=mediumHigh) ## The Annual Vacation Sale Members save up to 40% on hotels and homes. Plan this year’s big trip and save. [Book now](https://expedia.ca/deals?rfrr=CTG_SPRING_PROMO_553248635074843926) ## Frequently asked questions ### How much is a rental car per day in Fire Island Pines? ### What happens if I need to cancel my Fire Island Pines car reservation? ### Where can I go on a road trip from Fire Island Pines? > - You'll find Roger Williams Park Zoo and loads more amazing attractions in Providence. From Fire Island Pines, it's about 193 kilometres away. > - Why not see all that's on offer in Hartford too? Popular tourist attractions in this colourful city include Mark Twain House & Museum. Hartford is approximately 129 kilometres from Fire Island Pines. > - Plymouth Rock is around 241 kilometres from Fire Island Pines and is one of the region's most beautiful nature spots. Go for a walk around and enjoy the fresh air here. ### How do I find the best car rental deals in Fire Island Pines with Expedia? ### How old do you have to be to rent a car in Fire Island Pines? ### What do you need to rent a car in Fire Island Pines? ### What is the cheapest car rental in Fire Island Pines? ### Can I rent a car for a month or longer in Fire Island Pines? ### Where can I find a Fire Island Pines car rental if I am younger than 25? ## Car Rental Information | Popular car types: | [SUV](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/b/car-rental/suv?rfrr=car.table.SUV), [Full Size](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/b/car-rental/fullsize?rfrr=car.table.FullSize), [Economy](https://www.expedia.ca/lp/b/car-rental/economy?rfrr=car.table.Economy) | | -------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | Car suppliers available: | | | Our best deal of the day: | CA $66 | | Our second best deal of the day: | CA $91 | | Our third best deal of the day: | CA $93 | | From the airport to your hotel: | [Airport Transportation](https://www.expedia.ca/ground-transfers?rfrr=car.table.AirportTransportation) | ![](https://a.travel-assets.com/mad-service/footer/bnaBanners/BEX_Footer.jpg) ## Go further with the Expedia app Save on select hotels and earn double points when you book on the app. Our app deals help you to save on trips so you can travel more and manage it all on the go. Scan the QR code with your device camera and download our app