Find Hotels by Oakwood in Shelter Island

"Loved this boutique hotel. Very nice, clean and safe (solo traveler). Front desk staff was very attentive and sent messages to check to see if I needed anything. Everyone was friendly all the time and never got the impression that anyone disliked their job. Very enthusiastic and warm staff. Perfect location and in proximity to liberty Station, and the marina. Fun, restaurants, and bars within a five minute Uber ride"

"The property had its own concert venue and restaurant. Both were amazing! Staff overall were so helpful and friendly."

"The location was the most important thing for us. "

"Good location....a bit pricey.."

"The staff was very friendly, helping us troubleshoot some flight delays we were facing out of SAN. The area was close enough to walk to some nearby 24hr food places. Overall a solid place for the value. "

"A little confusing to find my room. Silly map. Had me cut through the pool."

"We stayed two nights and it had everything we needed. The bed was super comfortable. The staff was very polite and accommodating. We were very tired going over the mountains from Yuma, pouring down rain and windy. The lady checked us in early and she was very nice. She also recommended a wonderful restaurant near the wharf and in walking distance. "

"Not impressed but I guess for $93 in San Diego you get $50 quality. No phone in room, part of floor was broken, and we only had one towel. At 9am I tried to get front office to get us towels but was told they're all in the laundry. I decided not to shower and my roommate and his wife just shared a towel. Glad it was just one night"

"This was my second time staying at The Bay Club. It's nice and quiet, with convenient parking. It's just far enough from downtown to be quiet, but not too far for it to still be easy to drive back and forth from the convention center, the Cheesecake Factory, the Gaslamp quarter, etc. "