Search Shelter Island Heights Cottage Rentals from CA $161

"We had a wonderful stay here while visiting for a wedding. the bedrooms were both upstairs, FYI which I wasn't aware of from the listing but we made it work. The grounds were beautiful and lots of birds to enjoy. "

"We had a wonderful vacation at the Fairy Tale Guest Cottage. The location was awesome and we loved the accommodations, especially the fancy bathroom. Mark and Eunyoung are impeccable hosts. Would absolutely stay again!"

"Cute cottage, newly refurbished, quiet, nice neighborhood, well stocked."

"This property is perfect for 2-3 guests and located within short distance to town. The house is well built and very clean. Five Stars"

"A lovely beach cottage with bay views and easy walking access to the Atlantic beaches.The place was cozy and clean with expansive open views across reserve land to the bay.A bit tricky to find off the highway at night but we eventually got our bearings!"

"Perfect little beachfront cottage right on the water ...a few steps across your own beach. We had a very relaxing, comfortable visit."

"We stayed at this property last year and again this year. You can’t beat the location and the house is perfect for a group of family or friends. We had a lovely time and look forward to another stay in the future!"

"Lovely cottage on the Peconic Bay. We enjoyed our stay; found more than everything we needed. "

"Our family stayed at this quaint cottage in the North Fork. The cottage has a nice kitchen, gas fireplace, and well appointed bedrooms. I would love to visit in summer, it must be wonderful!"

"My friends and I had a great weekend here. The property is accurately described as listed. It was just enough space for a weekend. There were 3 of us. We used the fold down couch as the 3rd bed which was a good bed. Communication with the host was excellent. The property inside and out was great. We sat outside in the backyard for a while. The walk over the bridge to the Niantic boardwalk wasn’t too long when the weather is good. And we sat outside at Fat Tuna which was within walking distance...