Search Newcomerstown Cottage Rentals from CA $218

"Parking was plenty & safe. Breakfast couldve been hotter but had several options. Rooms were comfortable & clean.."

"View from balcony was amazing "

"This is honestly one of the nicest hotels I've ever stayed in. Everything was excellent. "

"Everything was good other than smelling cigarette smoke outside of our room. This is suppose to to be a smoke free resort. So we were very disappointed with that. I have migraines and the smoke triggered it for me to have a migraine. 😥"

"nobody at the desk at check in"

"My only complaint is that we didn’t book to stay longer! This home was immaculate, plenty of towels, comfy bed and bedding (plus extra blankets!), a wonderful assortment of coffee to enjoy while rocking on the wraparound porch. This home is nestled in the woods, but also minutes from wineries and the town of New Philadelphia, where we enjoyed live music at The Delaware and had a delicious take out meal of pizza, wings, and “Jo-jos” from Yours Pizza. We are already anticipating returning next year with at least another night stay! Additionally, the hosts were amazing-left a sweet note on the fridge, a letter on the table, and a folder of things to do. Thank you, Melissa and Tim!"

"Poor water pressure on 4th floor. No outlets on one side of bed, pillows were awful, overpriced for accommodation "

"Beds were very stiff. Brown water filled the hot tub. Two people in the room with only one regular coffee to be made in the morning. Ice maker outside room very noisy. Refrigerator in room just as loud as icebox. Walls very thin, adjacent rooms loud. Breakfast was very good"

"Property had the worst water pressure. Could hardly rinse the soap from your body. Hard not to slip in the shower because the water was so slow coming out of the shower head. Other than that it was ok."