Deadmans Cay Vacation Rentals

"Home has a spectacular view and amazing beach in front of the house. Violet was extremely helpful and changed her schedule to help us get into the house. She also gave us a lot of tips on where to go/what to do as it was our first trip to Long Island. Location was great on the south end of the island, near the marina and about 30 miles from Gordon's Beach which was beautiful. Would definitely recommend staying here particularly for a party of 2."

"The location is absolutely beautiful. Enough seclusion to enjoy the stay but very close proximity to grocery and a few restaurants. The property owner is wonderful and very helpful/easy to communicate with. 5 stars all around!"

"Quiet,secluded,and beautiful. All the comforts of home in a very special setting.Not only were Peter(owner) and Violet(manager) great communicators, they were gracious and accommodating in every way.Swimming , snorkeling, kayaking or just relaxing on the front porch with a cup of coffee,this place had it all.I can't wait to return to this incredible island and the little cottage across the Cay!"

"Beautiful views, cooling breezes, everything one might need in the house--everything worked including a nice little Weber grill. The beds were comfortable and there were plenty of towels. Great snorkeling right in front of the house although we did see one shark--it swam away. I would definitely stay there again."

"We had a fantastic time. The location is perfect. The beach at the house, was a great walking beach and swimming. It was close to good restaurants and other great exploring places. The house had a we needed to be able to relax and enjoy. Morning coffee on the beach is how we started each day."

"Wow! Amazing! We had a great time! The only thing you need to wear at Serenity is sunscreen. We stayed eight days and only seen two people walking the beach. For it being a public beach, it sure felt like our very own private oasis. The hut had about everything we needed for our stay including wifi . The king size net bed was our favorite place to hang out during the day to catch some rays and then at night for some star gazing. Tip: pack a flashlight, the nights are very dark when there's no moon out. The pictures and descriptions listed on VRBO are spot on, but you really need to be here in person to get a sense of the "serenity". The hosts were easy to reach and answer any questions we had. They even helped us set up a car rental and brought/delivered us some delicious pizza!"

"Really enjoyed our time though much too short. Wonderful property and great people."

"From the minute we arrived at the property, it was wonderful! Cathy greeted us and was extremely kind and helpful! The home was in excellent condition and the views were breathtaking! All the amenities were well thought out and in great condition! Thank you, Cathy, for all the help!"

"Beautiful and private! "