Search Chautauqua County Cottage Rentals from CA $186

"Very nice would absolutely stay again"

"We enjoy staying at Findlay Lake when we visit the ski area for the long holiday weekend. Sunny Side Up was a very nice and clean place. It was a little small for us and during the winter there is no access to the extended porch. We didn't spend a lot of time there (skiing all day) so it wasn't a big deal. We had a very nice time!"

"Amenities provided as stated were very helpful. Beautiful views from inside and out. Would rent again."

"Very clean and comfortable. Nice stay with plenty of towels, bedding, and kitchen equipment. Comfortable beds and helpful host."

"Cozy cottage is exactly the description this place should have! Owners were very accomodating, thank you both!"

"Absolutely lovely. Our family fully enjoyed the tranquility. Temperature control requires some attention, but the owners fully explain how to make it work well for visitors. Highly recommend."

"Nice place! Perfect for a small family!"

"What an amazing cottage. From the minute you walked in you had fresh bagels and snacks beautifully wrapped and with all of Deanna's special touches like slippers for the hot tub. Towels for everything. All the beach needs were there. She provided everything you could possible need for your stay. The BEACH was perfect and private all to ourselves, our family had a blast. The beds were so comfortable and the cottage was SPOTLESS. We will be back. "

"Cute cottage with a perfect view. Everything we needed was supplied. We could eat inside or outside. Plenty of space. Lived it. "

"Perfect little cabin in a great location. Good price and have no complaints. Thank you"

"We thoroughly enjoyed the combination of lake and creek views, and privacy of the property. It was fun to watch the evening swims from the nearby beaver dam, and listen to the daily arguments among the geese and cormorants. Off-site amenities were few during the off-season, which was not unexpected, but good to keep in mind when planning your visit."

"We really enjoyed the cottage and the location. Bonus: The culinary knives were sharp!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!It was very pleasant to sit outside under the amazing tree(s) and next to the canal. This is a central location, so we were able to easily drive to local attractions - even Presque Isle.Pots and pans are available; bring your own storage containers/sandwich bags/foil.Be sure to visit the fresh eggs and vegetable stand on the left as you head into Mayville! :)"