Find beach hotels in Baiting Hollow, NY

"My friends and I stayed at Billy’s house this past weekend, and we had an amazing time. The

is nice and only a short walk away. It was an easy trip to the wineries as well. The house was clean and the beds comfortable. There isn’t really cell service in the area right near the house, which Billy communicated beforehand, but the WiFi at the house worked perfectly for us."

"Lovely little cottage in a summer community. This house is cozy and newly renovated. 2 wide screen TVs. New kitchen and bathrooms and nicely furnished rooms. Sleeps 3. Has a lovely deck. Rustic walk to the

. We really liked it!"

"Our group stayed here over the weekend to visit some wineries. The location of the house was ideal. The owner did a fantastic job creating an inviting atmosphere with adorable farmhouse touches. The beds and couches were very comfortable. Everything was kept clean and tidy. We would definitely stay here again and I highly recommend it for anyone wanting to explore eastern Long Island."

"Beautiful house with amazing waterfront views. The woodsy surroundings and bird song were lovely. The community is very welcoming - someone we met on the

shared a paddle board with us for our entire stay! The house was well appointed and very comfortable. Made memories here!"

"This was the best VRBO property I have ever stayed at! Totally lived up to the photos. Gorgeous sunsets every night from our private setting. The house was immaculate and very tastefully decorated with every ammenity. Steps to the very private

. We'll definitely be going back!!"

"This sweet cottage is in a charming community, walking distance to a beautiful LI Sound

. You can walk for miles on this

connecting with nature. The cottage is in an ideal location for your exploration of the North Fork, with easy access to the South Fork as well. Perfect place for a couple to call home for a month. My elder brother and I used the bedroom and pull-out trundle couch/bed in the living room - both were cozy and comfortable. We loved sitting on the porch listening to the...