Find Historic Hotels in Allegheny Plateau, NY from CA $106

"A five-star property and five-star host."

"This is the perfect place to stay when visiting SUNY Geneseo. Lovely room, charming overall vibe. Sit down breakfast from 8-10a, really well done. And the kicker: a superb brew pub right next door, mellow not rowdy. Really glad we stayed here and will be back!"

"Gail, the innkeeper, made us feel very welcome. She was very nice and very informative. The breakfast was great. The room was big and quiet. We like the stand alone shower. Great stay. Great location. We enjoyed Geneseo and Gail helped us with that."

"Our entire stay was amazing! Glenda was so kind and accommodating. Our room was beyond our expectations and the breakfast was out of this world!"

"The room I reserved was supposed to be nonsmoking but had a strong smoke smell. Not a big deal for me as a former smoker, but if I was traveling with husband it may have been. Other than that it was fabulous all the way around. Service, room, amenities. "

"Very handsome house, well tended. Somewhat out of the way location."

"We were disappointed almost as soon as we entered our room. Although it was clean, it was crammed full of furniture with little floor space. The bathroom sink did not drain. We were told by the owner that previous customers had poured cereal and coffee grounds down the sink. It would have been preferred that she had assigned a different room if she knew that."

"Bed was very comfortable but the pillows were too thick. I felt like I was sleeping upright and had to sleep without any pillow. "

"Friendly staff when I checked in. Very welcoming of my two puppies. "

"Place was very clean and staff was friendly. Perfect location to walk around town. "