Ratings based on 6,138 Verified Reviews
They paid and stayed. We double-checked.
4.3 Room cleanliness
4.1 Service & staff
3.9 Room comfort
4.0 Hotel condition
They paid and stayed.
for Everyoneby NM from Winnipeg, MB
Great location, Great hotel!Posted 5-Mar-2014
We had the pleasure of staying at the New Yorker Hotel for 4 nights. We were up on the 37th floor, which actually worked out nice because it was quiet being that high up. The hotel staff was very pleasant and we were checked in in no time. The location was the best part! Right beside MSG center, right beside the subway and a short walk to times square, empire state building and much much more! The only downside was the size of our room which had the bed and hardly room for our suitcases. It would have been nicer and more comfortable to have a larger size room, although we weren't there to spend time in the room. (we travel frequently to Europe and the small size was comparable to European hotels). Another downside was the door to our hotel room wasn't very well sealed, it let in bright light all night long from big cracks around the door. It was definitely a safe location and the tik tok dinner attached served wonderful breakfast!! Over the weekend the hotel staff made sure everyone going to the elevators had a key card and it was very secure. There was construction going on at and around the outside of the hotel but it didn't bother us or obstruct our view one bit! We would definitely stay here again!
for Everyoneby Kafylou from Somerset England
Mum & Daughter trip to NYCPosted 5-Mar-2014
Pros: Location, very welcoming reception area and staff
Cons: Tea/coffee facilities in room or vending machine on landings
Location: Empire State building, Times Sq, 5th Ave. Subway entrance on corner right outside for A C E trains. Good if your coming in from JFK and Newark.
Great stay at the New Yorker, my love for NYC has been restored.
for Everyoneby John from Alexandria, VA
Good basic room in great locationPosted 5-Mar-2014
I had several meetings scheduled in different places in Manhattan as well as a theater play.. The New Yorker Hotel was a good base for the weekend.
for Everyoneby Kathy from Colorado
Art Deco and Midtown? Fabulous!Posted 4-Mar-2014
Pros: The New Yorker has a hard to beat location - midtown, and within walking distance to Times Square, and all of the plays/shows we attended.
Cons: The small bathroom needs a bit of updating, but it was very clean!
Location: Madison Square Garden, the theater district, Times Square, MoMa . . . all very close!
Our four nights at The New Yorker were lovely. Upon check-in, the woman behind the counter recommended a great pizza place, and other staff members were equally as friendly. This hotel is very quiet at night, which is a rarity in New York City! The decor in the lobby is not only beautiful but historic - even the lights above the elevator doors are created with Art Deco flair! Our room had two very comfortable, queen-sized beds, a bit of a view, and the housekeeping staff kept us happy with a coffee maker and coffee. Every staff member was courteous.
for Everyoneby Yorkshire Flyer from UK
Great central hotelPosted 3-Mar-2014
Good hotel in a very convenient central location. Staff helpful.
for Everyoneby A verified traveller
Good locationPosted 2-Mar-2014
Location: Great location near Penn Station and short walk to Javitz center
Lots of noise from the hall in the evening and early morning
for Couplesby Jaimie from West Yorkshire, England
Cons: maybe update decor in rooms?
Location: Madison square gardens just over road, about 5-10 mins walk from times square!
Great hotel, fab location! bar & diner attached to hotel so very convenient! would definately visit again!
for Everyoneby ian from Wales
Nice hotel near to Penn Station and Empire State.Posted 2-Mar-2014
Pros: A positive experience all round.
Location: Central location within walking distance of many sights.
Problem with faulty/noisy heating exchange unit first evening, which was resolved within an hour by duty manager with move to upgraded room. Staff extremely friendly, knowledgeable and helpful. Excellent location - Empire State Building, Macy's, central location. One block away from Penn Station with excellent links to Newark Airport. Tick Tock Diner located at Hotel, providing good breakfast and other dining if required.
for Everyoneby Laura from North West
Unbeatable locationPosted 1-Mar-2014
Pros: Location, clean, decor, 24 hour diner on ground floor
Cons: Size of room pretty small. Drink facilities in room.
Fantastic location to visit the city and perfect 2 minute walk from Penn Station at which to catch our train to JFK.
for Couplesby Chris from Cardiff UK
Good locationPosted 28-Feb-2014
Good location of hotel,MSG and Penn station adjacent,10-15min walk to 42nd St. Hotel was good (a solid 7/10)rooms were cleaned daily,free wifi in room,breakfast taken in the ticktock diner. Location is paramount and with penn station on your doorstep nyc is easy to discover. Our room was 3139,twin double with views of Hudson River.Would recommend this hotel